About Roger Rotter
Roger is a senior editor for the FOXSports.com fantasy group. Read his blog for more analysis. Have a question or comment? Send them!
MORE BY Roger Rotter:
 Trade watch: Give up Hamilton, acquire Fielder
 Rotter's rankings: Top 500
 Stats report: Delgado, Longoria have 10 RBI in 7 days
See all articles >  
FANTASY FOOTBALL VIDEO
 L.T.'s Fantasy
Video Home

FOX Sports fantasy experts draft, Part I



•  Free draft guide: Transform draft day into a title!

Welcome to the FOX Sports fantasy experts draft where the fantasy group and industry pundits convened in late June to pick the top fantasy football players.

Find out how which running backs make the first-round cut, how high top quarterbacks like Indianapolis' Peyton Manning and New England's Tom Brady are being drafted, where players like Philadelphia's Donovan McNabb and New England's Randy Moss hoping for a big comeback land, who are the next projected consensus fantasy stars like Chicago's Cedric Benson, the Giants' Brandon Jacobs and Tennessee's Vince Young and where the most talented rookies such as Detroit's Calvin Johnson and Minnesota's Adrian Peterson are climbing in fantasy drafts.

All 12 experts picked 16 players. Each team starts nine players — one quarterback, two running backs, two wide receivers, one flex spot (running back or wideout), one tight end, one kicker and one defense/special teams — and a bench of seven players at any position.

This league uses the FOX default scoring system.

Review every pick of the first eight rounds along with a compliment and question mark provided for each player. Here's a look at the .

First round
No. Player Owner
1 LaDainian Tomlinson, RB, SD Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: Scored NFL record 31 TDs w/ 2,323 total yards
  Question mark: Will he dominate a tougher schedule?
2 Steven Jackson, RB, STL John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Totaled 2,334 yards, 90 rec and 16 TDs
  Question mark: Will catches drop significantly?
3 Frank Gore, RB, SF John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Totaled 2,180 yards and 9 TDs
  Question mark: Will he stay healthy?
4 Larry Johnson, RB, KC William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Totaled 2,190 yards and 17 TDs
  Question mark: Will a holdout lead to slow start?
5 Shaun Alexander, RB, SEA Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Only a year removed from 27 TDs and is still only turning 30
  Question mark: Will his foot injury derail him again?
6 Brian Westbrook, RB, PHI Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Had best season as full-time runner
  Question mark: Will injuries hurt his production?
7 Joseph Addai, RB, IND Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Sparkled as rookie sharing RB duties
  Question mark: Will he handle full-time load?
8 Rudi Johnson, RB, CIN Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Avg 1,407 yards, 12 TDs in last 3 years
  Question mark: Will rookie Kenny Irons affect stats?
9 Willie Parker, RB, PIT Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Handled featured back role: 1,434 rush, 16 TDs
  Question mark: Will new spread offense be effective?
10 Laurence Maroney, RB, NE Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: He's the No. 1 RB after totaling 939 yards part-time
  Question mark: Can he handle full-time without injuries?
11 Reggie Bush, RB, NO Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Caught 88 rec for 742 yards as rookie
  Question mark: Can he stay healthy with more work?
12 Willis McGahee, RB, BAL John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Moves to better offense after averaging career 1,122 yards with poor Bills line
  Question mark: Can he stay injury free?

Second round
No. Player Owner
13 Peyton Manning, QB, IND John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Declining defense means more shootouts
  Question mark: Will rookie Anthony Gonzalez help?
14 Cedric Benson, RB, CHI Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Becomes the featured RB with departure of Jones
  Question mark: Can he handle full-time and be injury-free?
15 Travis Henry, RB, DEN Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Frontrunner to be No. 1 in a top offense for RB
  Question mark: Will injuries bite him again?
16 Ronnie Brown, RB, MIA Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: New coach plans to feature him extensively
  Question mark: Is offensive line good enough?
17 Marvin Harrison, WR, IND Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Avg 103 rec, 1,402 yards and 13 TDs in past 8 years
  Question mark: Will turning 35 mean big decline?
18 Carson Palmer, QB, CIN Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Threw for 4,035 yards and 28 TDs after knee injury
  Question mark: Will loss of All-Pro guard Eric Steinbach hurt protection?
19 Steve Smith, WR, CAR Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Still had 1,166 yards and 9 TDs in down season
  Question mark: Can Jake Delhomme rebound?
20 Clinton Portis, RB, WAS Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Rushed for 1,516 yards two years ago
  Question mark: Will he share time and remain healthy?
21 Maurice Jones-Drew, RB, JAC William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Scored 15 touchdowns as a part-time back
  Question mark: Can he produce big stats sharing load?
22 Chad Johnson, WR, CIN John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Avg 1,358 yards and 9 TDs in past 4 seasons
  Question mark: Can he score more than 7 TDs?
23 Terrell Owens, WR, DAL John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Had 85 rec and 13 TDs despite injured finger
  Question mark: Will he implode again?
24 Edgerrin James, RB, ARI Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: Ran for 1,159 yards with poor line
  Question mark: Can he average more than 3.4 yards?

Third round
No. Player Owner
25 Drew Brees, QB, NO Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: Led NFL with 4,418 yards in first season with Saints
  Question mark: Will defenses figure out the Saints offense?
26 Tom Brady, QB, NE John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Threw for 3,529 yards and 24 TDs with worst WR group
  Question mark: Will Randy Moss corrupt team?
27 Thomas Jones, RB, NYJ John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Is Jets' featured RB after placing 11th in rush yards with CHI
  Question mark: Will Jets offense provide enough TD chances?
28 Deuce McAllister, RB, NO William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Ran for 1,057 yards and 10 TDs despite sharing time
  Question mark: Will Bush reduce touches significantly?
29 Torry Holt, WR, STL Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Avg 94 rec for 1,412 yards and 8 TDs in past 7 seasons
  Question mark: Will he be injury-prone after turning 30?
30 Reggie Wayne, WR, IND Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Is productive as Harrison
  Question mark: Will stats drop by adding 1st-round WR?
31 Brandon Jacobs, RB, NYG Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Favorite to be Giants' featured back
  Question mark: Will he split carries with Reuben Droughns?
32 Marshawn Lynch, RB, BUF Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Slated to be the No. 1 runner
  Question mark: Can he handle full-time duties in pros?
33 Larry Fitzgerald, WR, ARI Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Matt Leinart expected to improve in 2nd season
  Question mark: Will Cards become a run-oriented squad?
34 Antonio Gates, TE, SD Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: He's the No. 1 receiver for San Diego
  Question mark: Will he receive enough catches as TE?
35 Donald Driver, WR, GB Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: He's a long-time favorite of Brett Favre
  Question mark: Will injuries derail his production?
36 Roy Williams, WR, DET John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Has talent to be game's top receiver in explosive offense
  Question mark: Will he remain healthy and be consistent?

Fourth round
No. Player Owner
37 Marion Barber, RB, DAL John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: He scored 16 TDs as a part-time back
  Question mark: Will he still receive numerous TD chances?
38 Marques Colston, WR, NO Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Emerged as one of fantasy's top WRs when healthy
  Question mark: Can he stay injury free?
39 Anquan Boldin, WR, ARI Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: He's averaged 1,303 yards in past 2 seasons
  Question mark: Can he score more than 4 TDs?
40 Lee Evans, WR, BUF Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Had the league's 6th-most yards last season
  Question mark: Will J.P. Losman continue to progress?
41 Adrian Peterson, RB, MIN Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Has the talent to be a top fantasy back
  Question mark: Will he stay healthy?
42 Javon Walker, WR, DEN Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Top talent is playing with strong-armed QB
  Question mark: Will Jay Cutler progress enough?
43 Ahman Green, RB, HOU Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Becomes the featured RB with Texans
  Question mark: Will o-line improve and can he stay healthy?
44 T.J. Houshmandzadeh, WR, CIN Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Had first 1,000-yard season and caught 90 passes
  Question mark: Can he play all 16 games without injury?
45 Marc Bulger, QB, STL William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Set career highs last season and added big target Drew Bennett
  Question mark: Will o-line reduce 2nd-most '06 sacks allowed?
46 Randy Moss, WR, NE John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: New attitude will translate to big comeback season
  Question mark: Can he stay on his best behavior?
47 Andre Johnson, WR, HOU John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Upgrade at QB will lead to double-digit scores
  Question mark: Can another WR emerge to ease double teams?
48 DeAngelo Williams, RB, CAR Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: He's primed to replace DeShaun Foster as No. 1
  Question mark: Can he handle bigger load and stay healthy?

Fifth round
No. Player Owner
49 Chicago D/ST Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: Top defense with high sack, turnover and TD potential
  Question mark: Will recent curse of Super Bowl runner-up hit?
50 Carnell Williams, RB, TB John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Expected to be Tampa Bay's featured back
  Question mark: Will he regain confidence and healthy to run like a star?
51 Donovan McNabb, QB, PHI John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Can be fantasy's top quarterback with a full season
  Question mark: Will he last an entire season?
52 Jamal Lewis, RB, CLE William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: A fresh start with an improved offense can pay dividends
  Question mark: Have skills and health declined too much?
53 Plaxico Burress, WR, NYG Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Has physical talent to be one of fantasy's top WRs
  Question mark: Will he finally find consistency?
54 Kevin Jones, RB, DET Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Showed he's a dynamic all-around back in Martz's system
  Question mark: Will he recover in time from foot injury and be No. 1 RB?
55 Todd Heap, TE, BAL Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Excellent receiver is featured heavily in conservative offense
  Question mark: Will he receive enough scoring chances?
56 Vince Young, QB, TEN Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Nearly impossible to stop running and can pass well
  Question mark: Will he learn to read defenses and overcome poor WR unit?
57 Jerious Norwood, RB, ATL Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Ready to be Atlanta's featured runner
  Question mark: Will Warrick Dunn render him ineffective as a fantasy starter
58 Hines Ward, WR, PIT Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Better year ahead with new offense and healthy Big Ben
  Question mark: Has physical style resulted into a decline already?
59 LaMont Jordan, RB, OAK Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Looking better to clinch No. 1 RB with Dominic Rhodes' suspension
  Question mark: Can he handle rushing load after injury-shortened season?
60 Kellen Winslow, TE, CLE John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Is Cleveland's top receiver for receptions
  Question mark: Will Cleveland find an effective QB for '07?

Sixth round
No. Player Owner
61 Calvin Johnson, WR, DET John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Combine off-the-chart skills with explosive offense
  Question mark: Will he learn pro game quick enough?
62 Darrell Jackson, WR, SF Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Becomes San Francisco's No. 1 WR with improving Alex Smith
  Question mark: Will he return to health and be effective with another team?
63 Julius Jones, RB, DAL Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Has opportunity to be Cowboys' top RB
  Question mark: Can he rebound from injuries and inconsistency?
64 Reggie Brown, WR, PHI Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Ready to jump to the next level as Philly's No. 1 WR
  Question mark: Will he achieve weekly and be consistent?
65 Tony Gonzalez, TE, KC Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Still Kansas City's top receiver
  Question mark: Will new QB in KC hurt stats?
66 Laveranues Coles, WR, NYJ Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Has never missed a game in 6 seasons
  Question mark: Will Chad Pennington be effective?
67 Deion Branch, WR, SEA Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Awarded Seahawks' very productive No. 1 WR spot
  Question mark: Will he find same rapport with Matt Hasselbeck?
68 Chester Taylor, RB, MIN Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Was productive as Minnesota's featured back
  Question mark: Will Peterson reduce him to a backup?
69 Joey Galloway, WR, TB William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Still outruns defensive backs at 35
  Question mark: Will he remain healthy and one of most gifted receivers?
70 Baltimore D/ST John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Aggressiveness leads to many sacks and turnovers
  Question mark: Will both loss of Adalius Thomas and Ray Lewis' decline hurt too much?
71 Santana Moss, WR, WAS John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Is one of most explosive receivers
  Question mark: Will Jason Campbell keep improving and run an offense well?
72 Adam Vinatieri, K, IND Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: Indy will be forced to score more with defensive defections
  Question mark: Will Vinatieri receive enough field-goal chances?

Seventh round
No. Player Owner
73 Vernon Davis, TE, SF Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: He's a physical beast who can run like a WR
  Question mark: Will he stay healthy and develop a rapport with Smith?
74 Warrick Dunn, RB, ATL John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: He still can be productive as a featured RB
  Question mark: Will Norwood make him an afterthought?
75 Jeremy Shockey, TE, NYG John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Remains integral receiver for Eli Manning
  Question mark: Will he overcome injuries to play all 16 games?
76 Chris Cooley, TE, WAS William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Is Washington's second-most effective receiver
  Question mark: Will Campbell find him enough?
77 Michael Vick, QB, ATL Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Can single-handedly win fantasy games for owners
  Question mark: Will he finally be consistent in another new offense?
78 Matt Hasselbeck, QB, SEA Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Pencil in 24 passing TDs every season
  Question mark: Will he shake the injury bug?
79 Braylon Edwards, WR, CLE Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Has talent and opportunity to produce 100-yard games
  Question mark: Will Browns find a quarterback to throw to him?
80 Tony Romo, QB, DAL Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: A full year as Cowboys QB could make him one of the top in fantasy
  Question mark: Can he withstand slumps common for a young QB?
81 Brandon Jackson, RB, GB Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Will be given every chance to win the starting job
  Question mark: Can he handle a featured back role effectively and without injury?
82 Matt Leinart, QB, ARI Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Has one of the game's top receiving duos
  Question mark: Will o-line give him time to throw?
83 Jon Kitna, QB, DET Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Threw for 4,208 yards in only first season with Martz
  Question mark: Will Lions' offensive line protect him?
84 Fred Taylor, RB, JAC John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Ran for 1,146 yards despite sharing time
  Question mark: Will Jones continue to reduce his playing time?

Eighth round
No. Player Owner
85 Ladell Betts, RB, WAS John Juhasz, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Was effective as Portis when he became No. 1 RB
  Question mark: Will Portis render Betts useless in fantasy?
86 Bernard Berrian, WR, CHI Gerrit Ritt, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Had a breakout season as one of Rex Grossman's favorite targets
  Question mark: Can Grossman rebound and be reliable?
87 Mike Bell, RB, DEN Mike Harmon, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Last year's impressive rookie is next in line after Henry
  Question mark: Will he receive a chance behind Henry?
88 Tatum Bell, RB, DET Derek VanRiper, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Led Broncos with 1,025 yards as featured back last year
  Question mark: Will he find enough carries in crowded backfield and continue to be inconsistent?
89 Mark Clayton, WR, BAL Peter Schoenke, RotoWire.com
  Compliment: Has great chance to emerge as Baltimore's No. 1 WR
  Question mark: Will Steve McNair still be effective in 13th season?
90 D.J. Hackett, WR, SEA Emil Kadlec, FootballDiehards.com
  Compliment: Has chance to be Seattle's No. 2 receiver
  Question mark: Will Bobby Engram and Nate Burleson take away catches?
91 Reuben Droughns, RB, NYG Roger Rotter, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Has more experience and productivity than Jacobs
  Question mark: Can he overtake Jacobs to receive ample touches?
92 Alge Crumpler, TE, ATL Michael Fabiano, NFL.com
  Compliment: Is very productive as Vick's favorite target
  Question mark: Will new offense reduce role as receiver?
93 Terry Glenn, WR, DAL William del Pilar, KFFL.com
  Compliment: Has shown he can co-exist with T.O. and post a 1,000-yard season
  Question mark: Will injuries plague him again?
94 DeShaun Foster, RB, CAR John Halpin, FOXSports.com
  Compliment: Has physical talent to be a competent fantasy back
  Question mark: Can he remain injury-free and run for first 1,000-yard season sharing time?
95 Vincent Jackson, WR, SD John Hansen, FantasyGuru.com
  Compliment: Has talent and opportunity to be a fantasy starter at WR
  Question mark: Can he achieve consistency despite inexperience?
96 Jerricho Cotchery, WR, NYJ Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
  Compliment: Almost posted 1,000 yards in first season of playing
  Question mark: Will Pennington continue to improve?


FOXSports.com >> Feedback | Press | Jobs | Tickets | Join Our Opinion Panel | Subscribe
Other Fox Sites >> FOX.com | FOX News | News Corp.
Statistical Information provided by: Stats, Inc
© 2008 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use