go to MSN.com
  autos     money     sports     tech     more    
  MSN home  |  Mail  |  My MSN  | 

Rotter's Rankings: Quarterbacks

by Roger Rotter

Roger is a senior editor for the FOXSports.com fantasy group. Read his blog for more analysis. Have a question or comment? Send them!

add this RSS blog print
Updated: February 27, 2009, 10:39 PM EST
Rotter's rankings: Top 500 | QB | RB | WR | TE | | | | |

Rankings: Quarterbacks
Rk P A Player Tm Bye
1     Tom Brady NE 4
2     Peyton Manning Ind 4
3     Tony Romo Dal 10
4     Ben Roethlisberger Pit 6
5     Drew Brees NO 9
6     Carson Palmer Cin 8
7     Matt Hasselbeck Sea 4
8     Derek Anderson Cle 5
9     Philip Rivers SD 9
10     Brett Favre NYJ 5
11     Jay Cutler Den 8
12     Eli Manning NYG 4
13     Marc Bulger StL 5
14     David Garrard Jac 7
15     Donovan McNabb Phi 7
16     Jon Kitna Det 4
17     Aaron Rodgers GB 8
18 20 Kurt Warner Ari 7
19     Vince Young Ten 6
20     Jake Delhomme Car 9
21     Tarvaris Jackson Min 8
22     Jeff Garcia TB 10
23     Matt Schaub Hou 8
24     Jason Campbell Was 10
25     JaMarcus Russell Oak 5
26     Trent Edwards Buf 6
27     Chad Pennington Mia 4
28 21 Matt Leinart Ari 7
29     Brodie Croyle KC 6
30     Kyle Orton Chi 8
31     Matt Ryan Atl 7
32     J.T. O'Sullivan SF 9
33     Brady Quinn Cle 5
34 48 Joe Flacco Bal 10
35     Gus Frerotte Min 8
36     Rex Grossman Chi 8
37     Alex Smith SF 9
38     Sage Rosenfels Hou 8
39     Damon Huard KC 6
40     Cleo Lemon Jac 7
41     Brian Griese TB 10
42     Trent Green Stl 5
43     Troy Smith Bal 10
44     Seneca Wallace Sea 4
45     Chris Redman Atl 7
46     Kellen Clemens NYJ 5
47 53 Josh McCown Car 9
48     Brian Brohm GB 8
49     John David Booty Min 8
50     Patrick Ramsey Den 8
51     Todd Collins Was 10
52     Shaun Hill SF 9
53     A.J. Feeley Phi 7
54 65 Byron Leftwich Pit 6
55     Kerry Collins Ten 6
56     John Beck Mia 4
57     J.P. Losman Buf 6
58     Chad Henne Mia 4
59     Andrew Walter Oak 5
60     Brad Johnson Dal 10
61     Matt Cassel NE 4
62     Jim Sorgi Ind 4
63     Billy Volek SD 9
64     Luke McCown TB 10
65     David Carr NYG 4
66     Matt Moore Car 9
67     Drew Stanton Det 4
68     Mark Brunell NO 9
69 80 Charlie Frye Sea 4
70     Kevin Kolb Phi 7
71     Matt Flynn GB 8
72     Dan Orlovsky Det 4
73     Erik Ainge NYJ 5
74     D.J. Shockley Atl 7
75     Brooks Bollinger Min 8
76     Brock Berlin StL 5
77     Colt Brennan Was 10
78 47 Joey Harrington FA --
79     Daunte Culpepper FA --

Please note by clicking on "add a comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

Member Comments


Add your comment
No comments yet.

Join Published League - Football Freakz - $100 1st place prize! FREE ENTRY! Competitive fun!!! JOIN NOW!

Ensley03Ensley03
(Report inappropriate content)

Tarvaris Jackson is terrible. A person would have to be blind AND stupid to put him that high, and ahead of Garcia? Gotta be the stupidest thing i've ever seen.

R8R_H8RR8R_H8R
(Report inappropriate content)

I hate it when people put Brady at the top of their lists! He thinks he's all that bragging about his eight picks. His offensive line is amazing! Thats why he gets all those touchdowns. Lets see how good he would be if he had the lions offensive line. Not very good. This year Brady will be behind manning. I can sense it in my balls.

RyanWilczewskisRyanWilczewskis
(Report inappropriate content)

no way is rothlesburger ahead of brees or palmer. again roger shows his moroness

scagmanscagman
(Report inappropriate content)

What's with everyone ripping on Rogers. The Pack have that kid surrounded by a pretty good team. I haven't watched him in preseason, but he played well last year when he came in against the Cowboys. Favre was the one who had sucked, throwing 2 picks before he got hurt. I think 17 is a pretty good spot for a decent QB on a talented team. He has the potential to have a good year. Maybe Garcia, Campbell and Schaub are a little low, but out of them, Garcia is the only one who has been a top QB in the NFL. If only the Bears had tried to pick him up...


(Report inappropriate content)

I don't see Ron Mexico on this list. What gives?

bigdaddy12345bigdaddy12345
(Report inappropriate content)

I had Daunte Culpepper on my team 1 year and he didnt get me anything. I say that to say this "Tarvaris Jackson"

BigogBigog
(Report inappropriate content)

Is V Young Is a por mans McNabb

BigogBigog
(Report inappropriate content)

What about Farve. Dose he have a running game. I mean I dont think he will be anythink without the play action passing game. I think the linebackers will just sit underneth and pick him apart. Remember 2006-07

BigogBigog
(Report inappropriate content)

I dont think Peyton Manning will be down but I think all his greatness id behind him. Both of this wideouts have lost some steps. That what I think

BigogBigog
(Report inappropriate content)

why do people think matt schaub is good anyway<br /><br />many "experts" have him top ten.<br /><br />when did he prove he could do that?

tombradyrules12tombradyrules12
(Report inappropriate content)

imc75:<br />how can you possibly say that when the only game they used film for was week 1 against the jets. they didn't use it in any other games and they still won 17 of those. Brady won multiple superbowls and mvp's before then anyhow, it's not like he sukcs without them or anything.

tombradyrules12tombradyrules12
(Report inappropriate content)

Has anyone been watching the Preseason, Jay Cutler is completing over 80% of his passes, plus with Marshall, Royal, and Stokley, Cutler is sure to have a very active year

mleet84mleet84
(Report inappropriate content)

Yeah, we'll see how well Brady does without his cheat films this year.

imc75imc75
(Report inappropriate content)

peyton manning has never not started a game. he will be back and better then ever. and its not his back that is hurt its his knee. he had an infected bursa sac. i dont think that has anything to do with your back


(Report inappropriate content)

Be wary of Peyton Manning this year. He's a good player but he's got some health issues with his back. Indy has the 2nd hardest strength of schedule this year. Food for thought. The steelers have the hardest schedule this year so also be wary of using a first round pick on him.

47guru47guru
(Report inappropriate content)

Drew Brees will be the no. 2 fantasy QB this year. Book It!!!

tdtroxtdtrox
(Report inappropriate content)

I'm sorry but I would take McNabb over the 7 QB's you listed directly in front of him! Just my 2 cents.

psusupamanpsusupaman
(Report inappropriate content)

Matt Schaub should be higher rank ??


(Report inappropriate content)

i love brett farve but he is to high on this list....i think he will have a productive year, but he is going into a new offense and did not work out in the off seson which was the key to his reamergance as a top flight qb last year

MHU8AMHU8A
(Report inappropriate content)

 advertisement

FOX SPORTS VIDEO

Federer outlasts Roddick
Hear from Roger Federer after winning his 15th Grand Slam title with an epic win over Andy Roddick at Wimbledon. Federer won with a 16-14 fifth set victory.
Glazer: Remembering McNair
FOXSports.com's Jay Glazer remembers the life of Steve McNair. The former NFL quarterback was found shot to death on July 4th.

FOX SPORTS STORE

 advertisement

Statistical Information provided by: STATS LLC
© 2009 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved.