Rosenthal gets answers from Selig
Actually, he's not. Selig still enjoys his job, and in another part of the interview he spoke with delight about the unpredictability of the pennant races, saying, "You can handicap football. You can't handicap baseball."
In truth, Selig is buoyant about the state of the game, even though the national economy is uncertain, even though Major League Baseball is unlikely to set an overall attendance record for the first time in five years.
Speaking from his office in Milwaukee, Selig addressed a wide variety of topics in a question-and-answer session with FOXSports.com, ranging from the controversial move of the Astros-Cubs series to Milwaukee to the possibility of Mark Cuban becoming Cubs owner.
Q: You have taken criticism for your decision to shift the Astros-Cubs series to Milwaukee's Miller Park after Hurricane Ike ravaged Houston last weekend. What happened?
A: Those have been questions in Houston, obviously. Look, what happened is the tragedy of the hurricane. We bent over backwards. We considered all of the options. I had three weather services I can keep you all day going through all this.
When we knew early Saturday morning about the devastation, we knew we couldn't play in Houston. We had to consider other options.
We called Minnesota. They had the (University of Minnesota) Golden Gophers (football game) on Saturday and the (Minnesota) Vikings on Sunday. In Arizona, the Diamondbacks were playing. Atlanta, all three weather services said there was going to be rain. Tampa, the Red Sox were playing on Monday. Washington ... we went through every alternative.
Q: St. Louis?
The storm went through St. Louis. You know what happened to Chicago last week. St. Louis got all that rain. All three weather services said, "Don't even think about going there."
Q: Texas?
A: Every weather service predicted that the storm would go right up through Texas and that the devastation might be worse. And Texas was playing at home on Monday.
We had decisions to make on Saturday. The more we went through it, the only option we had left was Milwaukee.
(The teams played two games at Miller Park, and the third game will be made up in Houston at the end of the season, if necessary.)
I kept the third game (in Houston). We're not supposed to do that.
We're supposed to play all the games during the season. But I gave Houston the third game if it means something the following Monday.
This was a tragedy.
I frankly wanted to go to Minnesota. The Cubs would have had a lot of fans there as well. Wherever the Cubs go, that (phenomenon) takes place. But Minnesota was out. We had no choice. Between the rain and the domes in use, we had no choice.
We couldn't send them out to the West Coast. The (Astros) had to be in Florida (on Tuesday night). If I sent them to Dodger Stadium or Seattle, they would have played a double-header Monday, then flown all night to Miami.
People can sit around and second-guess. But as I go back through my notes, there were no other viable alternatives. I couldn't send them somewhere where it was going to rain.
![]() |
| Playing in Milwaukee certainly worked out well for Carlos Zambrano and the Cubs. (Morry Gash / Associated Press) |
Q: Your options would have been greater if Astros owner Drayton McLane had agreed to postpone the games before the hurricane hit.
A: A lot of people are blaming him for that. I don't think it's fair. I want to protect Drayton. He was very hopeful that the hurricane wouldn't be as severe as it was. Only Saturday morning did we realize that we couldn't stay in Houston.
Q: Let's talk about attendance. Your paid total of 79.5 million last season was a record for the fourth straight year. What are the chances that you will set another record this season?
A: I don't think we're going to make it. But we're still in very healthy territory. As my friend George Will said to me the other day, "You can't break an attendance record every year." Given the economy and the weather and we've been really hurt by the weather we're going to come awfully close.
Q: Any concerns about the decline, however slight it might be?
A: No, none whatsoever. The average team will draw 2.5-2.6 million. At worst, it will be the second-best year in history. Between the weather and the economy, most people are surprised (by the numbers). And the gross revenues for the industry will be stunning this year, higher than I thought. Which, in a greater sense, is actually more important.
Q: If that's the case, should we expect a robust free-agent market?
A: That's an interesting question. Clubs have to make their own decisions. The sport has never been this popular or this successful. I have to say that. The fact of the matter is, the sport is extremely healthy in every way.
The economy is a grave concern for me. I don't mind telling you that. The last three days have been very troubling. But at the moment, it's easy for me to say that the sport is more popular than it has ever been.
![]() |
| Concerned about a possible attendance decline? Not Bud Selig. (Mike Stobe / Getty Images) |
Q: How worried are you about Tampa Bay? Here are the Rays, in the middle of a dramatic pennant race, and they're still not selling out.
A: OK, but I'm looking at their numbers. They're at 1.658 million, up almost 411,000. I guess we've got to watch it. I have concerns. But they're going to wind up at a number where they've never been before. It's an amazing story, one of the great stories.
I'm thrilled by it. It's a manifestation of everything I'm trying to do competitive balance, parity, all that. But of course, I have concerns. I think we need to watch that situation in the next year or two.
Q: What about the Washington Nationals? This is their first season in a new ballpark, and their TV ratings and radio ratings reportedly are terrible.
A: I still have a lot of confidence in the Lerners. I like (managing principal owner) Ted Lerner a great deal. He doesn't seem to be concerned.
The TV ratings are startling we need to get into that. The attendance is not that bad, given their team. They're averaging almost 30,000 a game.
I have faith that the Washington franchise is going to be a great franchise. They need to be competitive. They know that. Ted Lerner knows that.
Q: Instant replay. Baseball implemented it three weeks ago yet has used it only twice. How would you assess it thus far?
A: The two that we had worked out beautifully. The thing I like is that it has saved time.
Q: Some say that this is only the start, that baseball eventually will extend replay beyond home-run calls, using it on the bases and even on balls and strikes.
A: I meant what I said: As long as I'm commissioner, we're not going to expand it. The umpires are doing a great job. We have QuesTec. The umpires are rated far more aggressively than ever before. We just did this because of the configurations of the new ballparks. A lot of umpires told me that they just can't see.
Q: The players' union filed a grievance after first-round draft pick Pedro Alvarez refused to sign his contract with the Pirates. The union alleges that baseball violated the collective-bargaining agreement by allowing the Pirates to sign Alvarez after the deadline on midnight ET Aug. 15. Baseball admits that it extended the deadline for Alvarez and the Royals' No. 1 pick, Eric Hosmer. Why not just enforce all deadlines trade deadlines, signing deadlines to the letter?
A: I understand that people have said that. I'll accept that. I always say, sometimes you should use a little common sense. If you're talking about three minutes, eight minutes, 10 minutes, in everything I've done, I've always tried to use good old-fashioned common sense. It's one thing if it's 8 to 10 hours. But having said that, we will look at that.
Q: Some people within the sport believe that the Dodgers' three-way trade for Manny Ramirez was not completed before the 4 p.m. ET deadline on July 31.
A: Manny Ramirez was done. I have Rob (Manfred) involved in all of these things. He's our labor lawyer, a very good one. He tells me that deal was done before 4.
My job would be a lot easier if we adhered to the second. I don't have a problem with that.
Must-read:
Must-see:
Top headlines:
- Federer bests Roddick for 15th Slam
- Police rule McNair death a homicide
- Jeter, Pujols highlight All-Star rosters
Worth a thousand words:
Q: Mark Cuban, the owner of the NBA's Dallas Mavericks, reportedly is one of five finalists to buy the Cubs. Some, including myself, believe that the baseball owners never would approve a nonconformist such as Cuban to be a member of their club.
A: I've read that 1,000 times. None of that is true. People don't understand the ownership process. The ball is in the hands of the Tribune Company. They've got to vet a lot of people, as we do, then go through the bidding process. Then they will present anyone they want to us for approval.
(Tribune Co. CEO) Sam (Zell) knows what our economic rules are. We have a lot of 'em. We need 30 owners to approve it. We have had debates in the last 25 years about owners. Baseball has the authority to do that.
But it's a process. And (the Cuban talk) is way ahead of the process.
Q: Ten years ago, Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa staged perhaps the greatest home-run duel in major-league history. Yet, many are now ambivalent about the Summer of '98, viewing it as a byproduct of the Steroid Era. Looking back, what are your thoughts?
A: It was a very emotional time. I remember coming to St. Louis late in the season. The city was so excited. People were so excited. It was a great moment in baseball history. Unfortunately, we learned a lot as the years went on.
I still have great affection for both of those gentlemen. I must tell you that. But I'm proud of how we reacted to it, really proud.
We've got the toughest testing program in sports. Baseball has addressed the problem and for the most part has solved it. We'll continue to work hard, do things with the Partnership for a Drug-Free America. There isn't much more I can say.
Historically, it didn't produce the attendance boost that everyone said. I have the attendance from every year going back to 1901. People say, "The owners wanted to do this." But you know, in 1998 and '99, attendance actually dropped a little bit. We're at numbers now that you wouldn't have dreamed about 10 years ago.
Q: Finally, the toughest question of the day: Who is the National League MVP?
A: (Long pause. Selig mentions several candidates Albert Pujols, Ryan Howard, Manny Ramirez, CC Sabathia).
You know, I don't know. It's a very good question. There are a lot of candidates, for different reasons. I've got to think about that one.
Member Comments
Zambrano's no no should have an asterisk. If the players felt anything like the rest of us in Houston felt after IKE and then had to travel on game day to play, Bud served them up good. I just hope that Bud's beloved Brewers don't benefit from it. Maybe congress should have stepped in like they have been on everything else lately. Just kidding on the congress part. Hey Bud, Houston has some Duck Sausage for you!
trickyricky719/25/2008 5:27:00 AM(Report inappropriate content)
Bud Selig is a joke, from the all star game giving home field advantage, don't ask don't tell policy on steroids and then kicking the Astros while they were down. I understand that he had limited options but come on, Miller field and having to travel on short notice the day of the game, what a hose job. What about one of the Astros minor league affiliates, give those well deserving fans a treat and keep it a somewhat home field advantage? It is long overdue for a new comish!
trickyricky719/25/2008 5:01:00 AM(Report inappropriate content)
Don't think that's really fair to say that looking back on the first half of the season is a reason why a team would fail to make the playoffs. Some teams start the season good and then collapse i.e. NY Mets (2007, maybe 2008), and some start mediocre and get hot towards the end i.e. St. Louis Cards (2006 Championship). So where do you make your point? If games go down to the wire at the end of the year, its because of the competitive nature of the game. Teams struggle and fight to the end to reach the postseason. And because of it, the remaining games become more crucial as the end of the season draws near. MLB has already experienced wild-card teams playing that do-or-die game between clubs a day after the season ends just to see who makes it to October. If a team started out badly, well guess what, there is still the rest of the season to be played. That is why all the games are played and why teams make those ever important mid-season waiver/trade deadline aquisitions to boost their clubs. And for those teams that have a chance to shine in October, its all about "keeping" yourself competitive all the way till the end. Was Houston's competitive fire put out because of the distractions of Hurricane Ike and the last minute relocation/travel for its games? I would bet that it did. Did the games against the Cubs matter? Its the same as asking whether the Cubs got two wins in these games to reach their magic number, as the Astros were put two losses away from being in the wild-card. Besides, every game matters; more so for teams who are still in the playoff hunt near the end. Also, remind yourselves this, in every major sport, the playoffs and championship games are played when???? At the end. Because the last one still standing, AT THE END, WINS!<br /><br />Its like I said once before, its not that the Cubs dominated their opponent, they simply took advantage of the situation they were in. Any MLB team would have. Heck, even the 'Fish balled them (the Stros) out too. And pretty convincingly I might add. Yes, the Cubs are a great team, and a championship caliber team at that! But what was their win streak BEFORE they had those couple days to play the Astros? Do you guys recall? Two games folks. And were they in any kind of groove heading down the stretch? Nope. They were inconsistent. These games obviously were a major shift in momentum for both clubs. So was the change in venue any factor? Definitely, because everything was arranged and done at the last-minute. Houston players had to make an unexpected long trip only hours after weathering through a terrible calamity. The Cubs only had to travel down the interstate (in their own backyard) without the same distraction. Huge difference. So there you have it once and for all. For me, its like my boy Meth said in his own song, "Raw, I'm a give it to ya, with no trivia...."
9/19/2008 21:02:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
As a Cubs fan, I have been saying that the Astros have the upper hand in winning the wild card based on the rest of their schedule, but they stopped playing. They were dominated by the Cubs, and not because they were so close to Chicago, (remember Astros just took 2 of three from the Cubs in Chicago). They ran into Zambrano's best game of his career and followed up by Lilly's. Any team would been in trouble with those two pitching perfromances. If the Astros fail to make the playoffs, look back to how poorly they played in the first half, not two days at Miller Park.
datailes9/19/2008 17:09:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Houston fans remember this is not the first time ol uncle Bud stabbed us in the back . remember forcing the roof to be open in the 05 series. Because it was an unfair to the whitesox. And now this Miller Park deal what a crock of bull. Ol Bud was just looking out for his Brewers his choker Brewers. Who will not make the playoffs but took the stros down with them. You know if Mclane had any kind of cahjones he would have refused to go. Do you think Stienbrenner would 've ate that do do sandwhich? I don't think so. Now Mclane id donating one million to the Ike relief cool that money he made from the Cub series. Mclane is not a major league owner he is definatly the whipping boy of the NL.
astrototheend9/19/2008 16:13:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
bud selig, who believes anything from him , heres a guy who approves of drugs in the league, covers up drug users, and abusers and yet still dis avows pete rose for gambling goes to show what power, greed and association with owners can do ,
dayflyer9/19/2008 14:44:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
This is a pretty good interview, but misses a key question. How does Selig feel about having two sets of rules governing his game, i.e. the DH in the AL and not in the NL, particularly when interleague play has become so important, and when an exhibition game decides who gets the home field advantage in the World Series. I think that Selig should force the NL owners to adopt the DH and make it a universal part of baseball. The NL and its farm teams are now the only exceptions anywhere in the US. I'm not sure how foreign countries handle this issue. The Olympics had the DH.
dadlak9/19/2008 12:20:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Lemon eater Pud Selig is a leach!<br /><br />That was for you spurtsguy!
Pancho9/19/2008 6:29:00 AM(Report inappropriate content)
I say you have to play then entire season in one league to be eligible to win the MVP. Manny Ramirez just waltzed in well after mid-season, I just don't think its fair if he wins it. Same with C.C. Sabathia. Ryan Howard and/or Alber Pujols should win, they've both been going at it in the NL all season.
PooperScooper899/18/2008 20:27:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Vinnuie McMahon would luv putting the Cubs in BUDs city and claiming everything is kosher.. Sounds like Raw....
joepa879/18/2008 17:09:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Houston was done by the end of July? Really? Better check the wildcard standings again, parbuster, before declaring most people illiterate...
poeticadam9/18/2008 15:33:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Selig had one day to make a decision that would placate all of baseball, 30 teams not just the Astros and Cubs, sorry Astros fans thats the way the cookie crumbles, I wonder if they had of split if his decision would be under so much scrutiny, besides if they stay in the hunt they get a one game chance at the end of the season, which will not be against Zambrano who will be needed to pitch he first game of the DS, quit your whining and move on.
Prediddle9/18/2008 15:13:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
WARNING ? Stay away from ---s u g a r bab y m a t c h.c o m . . or . . . ww w.RichMatchMaking.co m******* . . . or . . . ? B l a c kW h i t e K i s s . c 0 m* . . . or mi xed cup id. C om . . . .or++++D a t e R i c h S i n g l e S.. c om++++ you will download a computer virus . .
9/18/2008 14:59:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Selig: (Talking about how attendance is down) "At worst, it will be the second-best year in history. Between the weather and the economy, most people are surprised (by the numbers). And the gross revenues for the industry will be stunning this year, higher than I thought. Which, in a greater sense, is actually more important." <br />Translation: Even though less fans are making it to the ballpark because of not being able to afford tickets, the owners are still making more money which is more important.
9/18/2008 14:37:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
The team with the best record overall has home field. Like every other sport. Plain & simple. Work hard to earn your home field advantage.
9/18/2008 13:59:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
For all of you who just won't give it a rest, how was alternating the home field each year more fair than the current system? Or were you geniuses even aware that was way it was done before. The current system isn't great, but how was it better before?
yepitsme9/18/2008 13:50:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
I can't believe all the drama I have heard about the game on sunday at miller park, I can assure you that if they rescheduled the brewers at wrigley field all the cubs fans would come and boo the brewers, regardless of who they were playing because cub fans have heart. and are smart enough to know that if the brewers feel comfortable in the statium, they might win and that would hurt the cubs. I don't get why everyone is throwing a fit about this. By the way the guy wrote wrote this article might be a writer but he is not a sports writer every article that he writes is slanted toward the east coast, he refused to acknowledge any cubs accoplishment
paintersix9/18/2008 13:46:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
What! Are you in bed with Selig?<br />You must think that All Star rule is fair too? What planet do you live on?
9/18/2008 13:27:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)
Seligs a good guy, he loves the sport, and he's contributed greatly to it's success. Back off him!
sportsguy20000009/18/2008 13:23:00 PM(Report inappropriate content)





advertisement

