go to MSN.com
  autos     money     sports     tech     more    
  MSN home  |  Mail  |  My MSN  | 

Red Sox, Yankees among teams eyeing Burnett

by Ken Rosenthal

Ken Rosenthal has been the senior baseball writer for FOXSports.com since Aug. 2005. He appears weekly on the FSN Baseball Report and MLB on FOX.

add this RSS blog print
Updated: November 19, 2008, 1:40 PM EST
In early September, a rival executive told me that the Red Sox were planning a major push for right-hander A.J. Burnett if he became a free agent.

The Red Sox indeed are interested in Burnett, according to major-league sources.

The question is to what extent.

The Sox generally resist giving long-term contracts to starting pitchers, the exception being the six-year deal they awarded right-hander Daisuke Matsuzaka when he was 26.

Burnett turns 32 on Jan. 3. The Yankees intend to offer him a four-year deal, according to one source, not the five-year, $80-million proposal that was reported as a possibility on Tuesday.

The Sox, in theory, could sign Burnett for a shorter term with a high average salary. But if Burnett wanted that type of deal, he probably could stay in Toronto.

The Jays, though, have yet to even make Burnett an offer; sources on both sides say reports of a four-year, $54 million proposal to the pitcher are inaccurate.

Burnett could end up taking the same approach as the Cubs' Ryan Dempster — testing the market, then returning to his previous team.

But with the Yankees, Red Sox, Braves and Orioles all showing interest, his price could rise beyond the Jays' comfort level, perhaps even to $20 million per season.

So, would the Red Sox go to four years on Burnett, given his well-documented history of injury and inconsistency?

Seems doubtful, but owner John Henry is a fan of Burnett's, going back to their days together with the Marlins.

The Sox, meanwhile, could use another starting pitcher to go with Matsuzaka, righty Josh Beckett and lefty Jon Lester — particularly if they trade one of their young pitchers for a catcher and/or keep Justin Masterson in the bullpen.

Beckett, who is under the Sox's control only through 2010, eventually will need to be re-signed or replaced. The addition of Burnett would provide the team with a buffer against Beckett's possible departure.

Hank "Broadcast News" Steinbrenner blurted out the Yankees' intention to pursue Burnett in late August. The Red Sox have been much more guarded about their plans, but Burnett is 5-0 with a 2.56 ERA in six lifetime starts against them — and 6-3 with a 2.43 ERA in 11 starts against the Yankees. No one questions his stuff, and one rival coach says he was "clearly more of a 'pitcher'" last season.

A bidding war for Burnett between the two AL East super-powers appears unlikely; the Red Sox likely would bow out before getting suckered into such a game.

Derek Lowe might be too old to get Barry Zito money. (Jeff Gross / Getty Images)

Then again, if the Yankees fail to land all three of their free-agent targets — Burnett, CC Sabathia and Derek Lowe — the Sox will be laying in wait.

Lowe equals Zito?

Those who snickered when Scott Boras intimated that he wanted a six-year deal for Manny Ramirez might guffaw at this one.

Boras, according to executives with two different teams interested in Derek Lowe, is telling clubs he wants "a Zito-type contract" for the free-agent right-hander.

That's Zito, as in Barry Zito, as in seven years, $126 million.

Zito signed the deal before the season in which he turned 29. Lowe, who has averaged 208 innings and a 3.79 ERA the past seven seasons, turns 36 on June 1.

Boras could not be reached Tuesday night, but he has called Lowe "the safest bet" of any free-agent pitcher.

Lowe earned 42 saves as a closer in 2000. He has a career 3.33 ERA in the postseason. Perhaps most impressive of all, he has never been on the disabled list.

The Yankees' other issue

While the Yankees are correct to focus on starting pitching, they scored only 789 runs last season, their lowest 162-game total since 1992.

The team expects to lose first baseman Jason Giambi and right fielder Bobby Abreu as free agents, and to this point, has added only infielder/outfielder Nick Swisher.

General manager Brian Cashman, however, does not sound especially concerned about the Yankees' offense.

"You take a step back, and we lost Alex (Rodriguez) for (three weeks) last year. Robbie Cano got out of whack," Cashman said.

"I expect Alex for the full six months next year — and look at the production he had (35 homers, 103 RBIs) missing one month. Cano is fine now. He's going to be a .300 hitter.

"I do believe we'll miss Abreu and Giambi and their selectivity. But the addition of Swisher will help."

And if Hideki Matsui and Jorge Posada make successful recoveries from their respective knee and shoulder surgeries?

"That probably answers the questions right there," Cashman said.

Still, the Yankees are always looking to improve and can not be ruled out of the free-agent pursuits for Mark Teixeria and even Ramirez.

If the Yankees added Teixeira, Swisher could turn out to be their version of Coco Crisp, offering protection against injury.

The Yankees consider Swisher to be above-average defensively in both outfield corners and at first base.

Wakamatsu: Intriguing pick for M's

Don Wakamatsu is an excellent teacher, according to a baseball man who knows him well, and particularly adept at instructing catchers.

Dustin Pedroia is just getting started. (Doug Pensinger / Getty Images)

That's good news for the Mariners, who are set to hire Wakamatsu as their new manager on Wednesday, according to numerous reports.

Several of the team's pitchers dislike throwing to Kenji Johjima, the Mariners' Japanese catcher. Fixing that problem alone would be a major boost for the club.

Something else to consider: Wakamatsu could hire former A's and Mets pitching coach Rick Peterson. The two knew each other from when Wakamatsu was a catcher and Peterson a pitching coach in the White Sox's minor-league system.

"Don Wakamatsu is a friend of mine," Peterson said Tuesday night. "I am very happy for him. It would be an honor and a privilege to be his pitching coach."

Pedroia: An MVP with upside

Asked about his reaction to Red Sox second baseman Dustin Pedroia winning the American League MVP award, Sox manager Terry Francona said, "I am so proud of him. And he still might get better."

Better?

"Experience is huge. And he seems to get stronger and quicker," Francona explained. "As long as he stays away from injury, he will continue to get more dangerous at the plate."

Pedroia is only 25, so it's entirely possible that he has not reached his peak. But he already has a Rookie of the Year award and an MVP. And, as the accompanying chart shows, his first two full seasons compare favorably to Derek Jeter's.

Pedroia vs. Jeter ... by the numbers
Player Games AB H 2B 3B HR R RBI SB AVG OBP SLG
Derek Jeter '96-97 316 1236 373 56 13 20 220 148 37 .302 .370 .417
Dustin Pedroia, '07-08 296 1173 378 93 3 25 204 133 27 .322 .378 .471

Around the horn

The fourth year of right-hander Ryan Dempster's new four-year, $52 million contract with the Cubs is a player option, so conceivably he could opt out at age 34. Staying with the Cubs offered Dempster another advantage; as a player with 10 years of major-league service, five with the same team, he has earned the right to veto any trade. He would have needed to negotiate no-trade protection with another club ...

The Yankees' farm system is strong enough to match up with the Padres if the teams revive their discussions on right-hander Jake Peavy. The Padres, according to one major-league source, told the Yankees that a deal would be possible even if the Yankees declined to offer right-hander Phil Hughes.

The Padres scouted Hughes in a recent Arizona Fall League game, but the Yankees have zero intention of trading him ...

The Rockies, after trading left fielder Matt Holliday to the A's, are content merely to listen to trade offers for third baseman Garrett Atkins and new closer Huston Street. The team also does not plan to pursue free-agent outfielder such as Pat Burrell or Adam Dunn, believing it needs more speed in the vast left field at Coors Field. Seth Smith and Ryan Spilborghs could form a platoon in left, and the Rockies have multiple options in center, likely ensuring that Willy Taveras will be the odd man out ...

The Mets want to add a right-handed bat in addition to a closer and a possible replacement for free-agent left-hander Oliver Perez. Jose Reyes and Carlos Beltran are switch-hitters, but after David Wright, Fernando Tatis is their biggest right-handed threat. The Mets are not high on Burrell, and free agent Raul Ibanez, a left-handed hitter, is not an ideal fit. Though Ibanez hit lefties better than righties last season, his career batting average against lefties is 25 points lower.

Please note by clicking on "add a comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

Member Comments


Add your comment
No comments yet.

I love how you put a space just so you can say xxx hole.. what are you like 12, or do you not have the vocabulary to insult someone with real words?

evilroot73evilroot73
(Report inappropriate content)

Note to Theo Epstein- PLEASE do not sign this guy ! The guy is way over rated ~! only about 5 games over .500 for his Career ! STAY AWAY from this Injury waiting to happen AGAIN

Liveone5Liveone5
(Report inappropriate content)

How do you spell Pavano in Boston? B-U-R-N-E-T-T.

robert0259robert0259
(Report inappropriate content)

Here's my two cents and you can quote Legends when the season starts.<br />If the Yanks sign Derek Lowe I am officially a Tampe Bay fan. End of story.<br />Lowe is another Red Sox doooshe bag. He was an as shole when he played for Boston. Why do you think they LET him go?<br />No Yankee fans, his stats are medirocre in a weaker than weak division. he hasn't pitched in the Beast that is the AL East in 5 years. he's like 40 years old.<br />If this is the best that Cashmen can do fire his lilly white as s right now.<br />I'd rather watch Acevados or Sanchez of any of the other young guns struggle to become big league pitchers than choke on Lowe in stripes.

yankeelegendsyankeelegends
(Report inappropriate content)

Hey Ken, steroid, corticoid and amphetamine dealers NEED all these MLB freaks that you write about. The HOF demands steroid-based freaks. Corked bats and phony pitching records too. When will Roid Clemens or Cal Ripken be returning to ESPN prime time???? MLB = WWE Why not write about Hulk Hogan's sterod program, it is much like Albert Pujols, Ryan Howard, Manny Ramirez and David Ortiz's.

LIVE_WRONGLIVE_WRONG
(Report inappropriate content)

fenwayredseat writes: "The Sox/Yanks will always be the premiere rivalry in sports and this off-season will be a battle ground to see who is going to be left standing come October '09."<br /><br />Amen bros, grew up in Brighton off Cleveland Ave, w/Reggie Smith as my favorite player when everyone was glorifying Yaz, anyway, the problems with the economy are going to show to a certain degree what the sports world's all about, and two separate constellations collide when the Red Sox & Yankee's go after free agents - will they implode, will they conquer and divide players within reasonability, so much to factor - and so riveting, yet nothing's more interesting for my dollar value than watching the home grown Red Sox and seeing these kids really play the game well, Ellsbury, Pedroia and the gang...great team to watch at this depression era type of economic conditions, and though I'm in Wyoming and can only support the Boston teams from afar it must be spectacular to feel the victories from the NFL, NBA and MLB the last few years as a fan!!!

matrixnovmatrixnov
(Report inappropriate content)

I can't believe that I am saying this, being a lifetime Sox fan but...those that think the Yankees are a thing of the past are sadly mistaken. With this new stadium, it will bring them so much more revenue and we all know how dangerous they are w/ revenue. <br /><br />The Sox/Yanks will always be the premiere rivalry in sports and this off-season will be a battle ground to see who is going to be left standing come October '09.

fenwayredseatfenwayredseat
(Report inappropriate content)

nqhs<br />11/19/2008<br />5:58 PM (report inappropriate content)<br /><br />"Somebody wake smeg up. Comparing Padroia to Jeter? Are you kidding me? When Padroia is in the Hall of Fame and is wearing all those World Series rings you let us know. Typical sox fan." One more comparison ROY Pedoria 1 Jeter 0. MVP Pedroia 1 Jeter 0. nyjeter, I don't know if you noticed but he has only been in the league for 2 years. I think that if he continues to play at this level he will be joining Mr. Jeter in the HOF and will come close to matching the 4 rings that Jeter wears.<br /> <br /><br />First of all Jeter has won the ROY so they share that. Ped has the League MVP but Jeter has Allstar game and World Series MVPs. <br /><br />Pedroia deserved the MVP. He is a really good player but you cannot compare 2 guys that are at different points in their careers. As a fan of baseball it would be great if Pedroia maintains a consistent career. <br /><br />All day long you guys talk about the same crap. Spending too much, you need this and you stink. You sound like babies not baseball fans. There is a reason that the ratings for teams like the yanks and sox are high and that is because they want to win. There is no better rivalry in any sport so if they both want to spend it is going to make the showdown that much better.

tbonet26tbonet26
(Report inappropriate content)

you can have burnett-he had one good year out of 3 in toronto...go nuts-open the vault up and cross your fingers.<br />He was happy to take the jays money and ride the pines for a year's worth of games...

boomer828boomer828
(Report inappropriate content)

The Yanks miss the playoffs once in 13 years and you are all quick to write off the Franchise..Tards!!

IronHorse4IronHorse4
(Report inappropriate content)

Good trade for the Redsox. Ellsbury is younger, better arm and faster than Crisp and he will be a better hitter. What do you think? Chat with me on "B l a c k W h i t e K i s s . c o m" where all Men can find real black or white beauties online with photos,... who enjoying chatting sports and stars..

SexyMama5975SexyMama5975
(Report inappropriate content)

But if they were to live in the present, what would they have to talk about?<br /><br />Giambi's mustasio?

bloodredsoxbloodredsox
(Report inappropriate content)

I have said it to my Yankee fan friends and I will say it now to all of you. I never thought that I would see the day that the yankee fans were living in the past. This is a what have you done for me lately league. What have your beloved yankees done for you lately? Derek Jeter can no longer get to balls to his left. His offense is starting to tail off. If I had to pick one in their prime I might lean towards Jeter only because Pedi has yet to reach his. But if you were to ask me who I would take right now I would have to lean towards Pedi. Not a knock on any of Jeters accomplishments because in his prime he was an elite shortstop, the key word being WAS.

nqhsnqhs
(Report inappropriate content)

ah yas,but could Jeter provide this laundry quick enough or git to the laundrymat before Pedi<br /><br />Whoever is comparing Pedi and Jeter should do us all a favor and stop.<br /><br />Jeter is at the backend of his career while Pedi has just proved that he is legit once again. Pedi can hold his own 'gainst anybody! And fer you hata's...the line forms here.<br /><br />Apples and oranges people

bloodredsoxbloodredsox
(Report inappropriate content)

Look at all the hata's hating...<br /><br />What's wrong boys, nuttin to talk 'bout?<br /><br />Pedi is Knobhead? Have you seen Pedi throw it to first base?<br /><br />Nuff said.<br /><br />Enjoy the off season and whateva you gitting outta this sewing circle girls...<br /><br />Man, this is fun!<br /><br />-Blood

bloodredsoxbloodredsox
(Report inappropriate content)

The article lead was about teams vying fer Burnett was it not?<br /><br />Does someone need a hug?

bloodredsoxbloodredsox
(Report inappropriate content)

Chuck Knoblauch couldn't even carry Pedroia's jock strap on his best roided up days.

nqhsnqhs
(Report inappropriate content)

There you go, los923's got it, Joe Cronin. Let's compare P to Joe Cronin. Like i said, when/if P does all that, we'll compare. until then, he's nothing more than chuck knoblauch.

nyjeternyjeter
(Report inappropriate content)

"Somebody wake smeg up. Comparing Padroia to Jeter? Are you kidding me? When Padroia is in the Hall of Fame and is wearing all those World Series rings you let us know. Typical sox fan." One more comparison ROY Pedoria 1 Jeter 0. MVP Pedroia 1 Jeter 0. nyjeter, I don't know if you noticed but he has only been in the league for 2 years. I think that if he continues to play at this level he will be joining Mr. Jeter in the HOF and will come close to matching the 4 rings that Jeter wears.

nqhsnqhs
(Report inappropriate content)

As a Yankee fan I dont want Burnett... Skavoovied is right, too risky..

jarhead444jarhead444
(Report inappropriate content)

 advertisement

FOX SPORTS MLB VIDEO

Full Count: Handling Hairston
FOXSports.com's Ken Rosenthal has the latest news from the league. Find out where Padres outfielder Scott Hairston could be headed.
Rosenthal: Manny's return
FOXSports.com's Ken Rosenthal on Manny Ramirez. Hear what he thought about Manny's return.

FOX SPORTS STORE

 advertisement

Statistical Information provided by: STATS LLC
© 2009 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved.