go to MSN.com
  autos     money     sports     tech     more    
  MSN home  |  Mail  |  My MSN  | 

Finger pointing may hurt Manuel in long run

by Ken Rosenthal

Ken Rosenthal has been the senior baseball writer for FOXSports.com since Aug. 2005. He appears weekly on the FSN Baseball Report and MLB on FOX.


add this RSS print
Updated: June 12, 2009, 11:04 PM EDT
Comment
Joe Torre's greatest strength as Yankees manager was his ability to deflect attention away from players.

Mets manager Jerry Manuel does just the opposite.

Manuel, in baseball parlance, "throws guys under the bus." His candor appeals to fans who are tired of hearing excuses for overpaid, underperforming players. But such an approach rarely works long-term.

For now, all is relatively calm in the Mets' turbulent universe; the team, despite a series of debilitating injuries, is competing valiantly entering its weekend series against the Yankees (MLB on Fox, Saturday, 4:10 p.m. ET).

If the season ended today, the Mets would be a half-game back in the National League wild-card race and Manuel would be a candidate for NL Manager of the Year. But the season does not end today. And in September, when the Mets face renewed questions about their two previous collapses, they will need Manuel to be calm and reassuring.

So far, that has not been his style.

Manuel is not Ozzie Guillen, issuing rat-a-tat criticisms and threats to the White Sox on almost a daily basis. But he is also not Charlie Manuel, who rarely calls out specific players and receives unwavering loyalty from the Phillies in return.

As a media member, I certainly appreciate Manuel saying, "We can't keep sugar-coating things because that's not real." But while I like Manuel a great deal, I'm not sure I would like playing for him.

The whole Reyes batting third thing got the ball rolling. (Jim McIsaac / Getty Images)

Consider:

  • Mid-February. Manuel informs the media of his plan to bat leadoff man Jose Reyes third without first informing Reyes. The experiment, predictably, never gains traction.

  • Late March. Manuel announces that Daniel Murphy will be his everyday left fielder, saying he is a better hitter than Ryan Church, a more established player.

    "I don't want him to get strictly into a platoon situation," Manuel says of Murphy. "I think he's a little better player than that."

    Murphy, whom some in the organization view as the Mets' answer to Paul O'Neill, is now platooning with Fernando Tatis at first base.

  • April 29. Manuel removes backup catcher Ramon Castro by summoning Omir Santos from the bullpen to pinch-hit with the bases loaded, two outs in the ninth inning and the Mets trailing the Marlins, 4-3.

    Castro already has two hits in the game, but Manuel says afterward that he preferred Santos' shorter swing against Marlins closer Matt Lindstrom, disregarding that Castro also hits fastballs well.

    Santos pops up for the final out. A month later, the Mets trade Castro to the White Sox.

  • May 18. Church again. Manuel refuses to address him by name after the outfielder misses third base and the Dodgers successfully appeal in the 11th inning of a game the Mets lose, 3-2.

    "A guy missed third base," Manuel says. "That's unbelievable. I can't explain, why, how or anything."

    David Wright got a day off due to "anxiety." (Al Bello / Getty Images)

    The next day, Manuel denies a rift with Church.

  • May 29. Manuel uses the "A" word — anxiety — to explain why he is resting one of the Mets' best players, third baseman David Wright, for a home game.

    "I think anxiety has something to do with it, wanting to do so well in front of the home crowd, those type of things," Manuel says, citing Wright's better road statistics. "I believe he'll eventually turn that around, get comfortable here in these surroundings."

    Wright disagrees, saying, "I just think it's two months of a game that is already tough to be consistent at. I don't feel any different playing here than I do on the road."

  • June 4. Manuel criticizes right-hander Mike Pelfrey for getting rocked by the Pirates while pitching on an extra day's rest.

    "I was a little discouraged at Mike being where he was today after getting a day off, and kind of knowing what we needed and just not having it," Manuel says. "That was kind of disheartening, because we really needed this game today."

    And there's more.

    Manuel has upset some veterans by declining to give them advance notice of days off. He even sounded as if he was sending a subtle message to Mets general manager Omar Minaya when, referring to his injury-depleted roster, he said, "I have to deal with what I have."

    Some of Manuel's comments probably are more harmless than they appear in print. Some Mets players are not even aware of them; the team no longer makes the New York tabloids available in the clubhouse, the better to block out negative media coverage.

    Still, you wonder where this is all going.

    Manuel largely escaped blame for the Mets' breakdown last September; the team simply ran out of relievers, and Willie Randolph was the manager until June 17. Minaya actually might merit more blame if the team flops again; he's the one who chose Oliver Perez over free-agent starters Derek Lowe and Randy Wolf and left the club with little minor-league depth for reinforcements and potential trades.

    The question, in the end, is accountability. Manuel is right to hold his players accountable, but he need not do it so publicly. Accountability also works both ways. It can't always be someone else's fault.

    If Manuel wants his players to support him, he needs to support them. Everybody on the bus, no one under it.

  • Please note by clicking on "add a comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

     advertisement

     advertisement

    Statistical Information provided by: STATS LLC
    © 2009 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved.