This Magic show is no disappearing act

by Charley Rosen

Charley Rosen is FOXSports.com's NBA analyst and author of 15 books about hoops, the current ones being The First Tip-Off: The Incredible Story of the Birth of the NBA and No Blood, No Foul.

Updated: November 18, 2008, 11:10 PM EST 41 comments

add this RSS blog Print

With the win, Orlando now sports an 8-3 record that is certainly comparable to the league's bona-fide elite teams. But here's the question that the Magic will struggle to answer as the season progresses: Is this team for real?

YES, THEY ARE

Charley's NBA tour

Charley Rosen FOXSports.com's Charley Rosen has been watching every team closely this season. Now he has a scouting report on each one.
Eastern Conference
Atlantic
Central
Southeast

76ers

Pistons

Bobcats

Nets

Bulls

Magic

Celtics

Bucks

Heat

Knicks

Pacers

Wizards

Raptors

Cavs

Hawks
Western Conference
Northwest
Pacific
Southwest

Thunder

Suns

Rockets

Nuggets

Kings

Grizzlies

Wolves

Lakers

Spurs

Blazers

Clippers

Mavs

Jazz

Warriors

Hornets

  • Dwight Howard is a bully on the boards. And while he rarely makes any kind of spin moves in the low post, he's strong enough to always be a threat down there. Also, Howard's low-post defense is vastly improved — he now works hard to front and three-quarter opposing pivotmen, mostly to good effect. He's also become a potent shot-blocker.

  • Jameer Nelson is a power-point guard who delights in utilizing high screens. He may be smallish and not a speedster, but he can shoot, drive and dish with anybody. And he simply abused the inexperienced Will Solomon, who started in lieu of the injured Jose Calderon.

  • Rashard Lewis is an accomplished one-on-one scorer. Like Howard, he's also more active on low-post defense than he's ever been.

  • Mickael Pietrus was out with an injury, but his spidery defense and long-distance bombing have boosted the Magic on both ends of the court. Toronto missed Calderon much more than Orlando missed Pietrus.

  • J.J. Redick got the start instead of Pietrus and proved that he can nail open jumpers.

  • Hedo Turkoglu remains the unsung hero of the offense. He can shoot from the outskirts, use his hefty body and tricky crossovers to get into the lane, finish with either hand, and also make pinpoint passes on the move. In tight games, he's the Magic's go-to guy.

  • Keith Bogans can defend, shoot treys, and plays like a smaller version of James Posey.

  • In Nelson, Turkoglu and Lewis, the Magic have a trio of dependable and versatile scorers. Whatever points Howard can generate on his own cognizance are strictly gravy.

  • The Magic's team defense is more alert and more coordinated than at any other time in recent memory.

  • Above all, they're playing with confidence.

    NO, THEY AREN'T

  • Howard has problems defending guys who can face up and either shoot or go. Also, he still commits too many unnecessary fouls. And his effective shooting range is about three feet. It remains to be seen if he can consistently make judicious decisions when he's doubled — something the Raptors never bothered to do.

  • Like Howard, Lewis' defense is vulnerable to foes who can play facing the basket.

  • Nelson can be beaten off the dribble by quicker, more athletic guards, and posted by bigger guards.

  • Turkoglu has difficulty staying in touch with his man on defense when he's confronted with any kind of cross-screen or down-screen in the vicinity of the baseline.

  • The second unit is lacking in firepower, but here's where Lewis gets to shine. Even so, the Magic could use another creative scorer off the bench.

  • Redick can't create a shot with his dribble, and his intelligence is routinely trumped by his lack of quickness on defense.

  • Tony Battie is strictly a finesse player.

  • Anthony Johnson is another power-point guard, but his lateral mobility is not what it used to be. That's why the Magic desperately need a younger, quicker backup for Nelson.

  • Except when various screens, cuts and curls are employed to free up Redick, the Magic depend too much on high screen/rolls and individual skills to generate their shots.

  • Marcin Gortat is helpless on defense, and the Magic are also in dire need of a muscular substitute for Howard. When Howard sits, Orlando's ability to rebound is severely compromised.

  • Too often the weak-side defensive help is late arriving when either Howard or Lewis fronts the low post.

    Overall, the Magic are better than they were, but not quite as good as they need to be to battle on even terms with the NBA's top-tier ball clubs. As they are currently constituted, however, the Magic are a very dangerous team that nobody is eager to confront in the playoffs.

    But give them a few more spare parts and another season to get their collective mojo working at peak proficiency, and the Magic will really be for real.

    Straight Shooting

    Since Kobe Bryant recently passed Larry Bird's career point total, it's only natural to compare these two superstars. So, here's my two cents:

    If Bird was a better shooter, Kobe is much more creative.

    Although they were both shoot-first players, Bird has the edge in the passing department — one reason for this being that he was usually surrounded with better teammates.

    Bird was a superior rebounder, because of his size advantage and because he often played the power forward slot.

    Kobe is a better man-to-man defender, but Bird had a more evolved understanding (and execution) of team defense.

    Bird's instincts and anticipation remain unsurpassed, while Kobe is a vastly superior athlete.

    Both were peerless in the clutch, and their respective competitive spirits were likewise unparalleled.

    Bird was a much more formidable trash-talker.

    Bird was much more coachable and more popular with his teammates.

    Kobe is quicker, has a better handle and more dynamic ups, but neither was a powerhouse.

    Bird had a better left hand.

    Had Bird not spent so much of his career playing with Kevin McHale and Robert Parish, Kobe would still be trailing him in career scoring. It should also be noted, however, that because of the modern prohibitions against hand-checking and cut-bumping, it's much easier to score now than it was then.

    So who's the better player? Don't ask me.

    Vox Populi

    Why are certain players credited as being great (like Kevin Garnett or Dirk Nowitzki) when they don't normally score or contribute when it matters like in crunch time? — Sean, CA

    If you have a question or comment for Charley Rosen, submit it below and Charley may just respond.

    Subject:
    Comment/Question:
    Name: 
    Email: 
    Hometown: 

    Because the media hoops pundits and image-makers are unduly influenced by numbers.

    Because guys like KG and Nowitzki do have incredible skills that make incredible highlight snippets. Because they usually engage in cooperative and interesting interviews. And because they manage to stay out of trouble.

    In other words, all the wrong reasons.

    Travels with Charley

    There was (and hope there still is) a fantastic restaurant in Savannah simply called "Mrs. Wilkes." The place had no identifying signage and never advertised. Yet all the locals knew about it, so there were lines around the block for the only two meals they served, breakfast and lunch.

    It was an all-you-can eat establishment and the customers sat at long tables, usually in the company of strangers. Waitresses brought heaping platters of choice southern chow — fried chicken, catfish and okra. Collard greens, black-eyes peas, mashed this, stewed that. Everything was absolutely scrumptious, and there was no way to avoid overeating.

    Well, one fine day my good buddy Gerald Oliver brought his Charleston Gunners to town for a game against the team I was coaching, the Savannah Spirits. A native of Tennessee, Gerald just loved to eat down-home food.

    So on the afternoon before we were scheduled to play, I told Gerald about Mrs. Wilkes. Great food in unlimited quantities at an incredibly low price. And seeing as how he'd never find it by himself, I offered to join him and his players for a mid-day repast.

    Naturally, both Gerald and his team ate much more than they usually did for a game-day lunch. No surprise that they were bloated and lethargic come game time. Nor that the home team coasted to an easy win.

    Afterwards, Gerald could only laugh at my ploy. "You know something, Charley," he said in a whisper. "Having a meal like that reminded me of how my mother used to cook when I was growing up. You know something else, Charley. Losing the game was almost worth it. Almost."

  • Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

     advertisement

    FOX SPORTS NBA VIDEO

    On The Edge: Charles Barkley
    Charles Barkley has always been loud and outspoken. FOXSports.com re-lives some of the best and worst of what Sir Charles has had to say over the years.
    Cavs crush Celtics
    The Cavaliers remain unbeaten at home after a 98-83 win over the Celtics. Mo Williams had 13 points in the big win and talks to FSN after the game.

    FOX SPORTS STORE