FOX Sports Video
go to MSN.com
  autos     money     sports     tech     more    
  MSN home  |  Mail  |  My MSN  | 

Hawks not title ready yet

by Charley Rosen

Charley Rosen is FOXSports.com's NBA analyst and author of 15 books about hoops, the current ones being The First Tip-Off: The Incredible Story of the Birth of the NBA and No Blood, No Foul.

add this RSS blog print
Updated: December 19, 2008, 5:49 PM EST
Comment

After last season's elbow-throwing, trash-talking, seven-game playoff series, there's still some bad blood between Boston and Atlanta. Still, the pressure was on the Hawks to avenge their early-season one-point loss in Boston, and to also prove that winning three of three games at home in last season's series wasn't a fluke.

Charley's NBA tour

Charley Rosen FOXSports.com's Charley Rosen has been watching every team closely this season. Now he has a scouting report on each one.
Eastern Conference
Atlantic
Central
Southeast

76ers

Pistons

Bobcats

Nets

Bulls

Magic

Celtics

Bucks

Heat

Knicks

Pacers

Wizards

Raptors

Cavs

Hawks
Western Conference
Northwest
Pacific
Southwest

Thunder

Suns

Rockets

Nuggets

Kings

Grizzlies

Wolves

Lakers

Spurs

Blazers

Clippers

Mavs

Jazz

Warriors

Hornets

On the basis of this intense and hugely entertaining contest, here are some reasons why Atlanta is almost ready for prime-time competition:

  • They're an incredibly athletic squad, with Marvin Williams being by far the most athletic and Mike Bibby the least athletic.

  • When they can get out and go, they're virtually irresistible in a broken field.

  • Joe Johnson is a sterling defender.

  • J.J. is also the Hawks most creative scorer. Yet when he was doubled on every catch throughout the initial three quarters, Johnson was more interested in play-making than point-making.

  • In the critical 4th quarter, the Hawks found ways to discourage the Celtics from doubling Johnson. They set up a three-man triangle that created too much space for any weak-side defender to cover in order to help on J.J. — who promptly buried a midrange jumper. And they also moved the ball from side-to-side while Johnson executed a circle route that terminated when he accepted a handoff at the top of the key — and then looked for his shot.

  • Johnson also had time and space to create his own scoring opportunities whenever he carried the ball across the time line.

  • Flip Murray is a professional scorer off the bench.

  • Bibby has unlimited range.

  • The Hawks were extremely aggressive on defense, running down most loose balls and constantly threatening every passing lane.

  • Despite their lack of a true center, Atlanta certainly held their own in the rebounding department.

  • The unselfishness on offense is an important indication that this young team is rapidly maturing.

  • None of the Hawks were at all intimidated by the defending champs.

  • Early on, their strategy of playing soft defense against Kevin Garnett — and even helping off him — paid handsome rewards as KG missed a double-handful of open jumpers.

    On the other hand, here's why the Hawks are still not quite ready to mount a legitimate challenge for a championship:

  • While Josh Smith had his moments of grandeur, he's still not fully recuperated from his latest injury and isn't at the top of his game.

  • Smith plays defense as though he was on roller skates — always backing away and looking to block shots.

  • Bibby isn't quick enough to penetrate into the paint — which he managed to do only once — and is therefore strictly a perimeter shooter.

  • At times, their defense was too aggressive and left the basket unattended.

  • Whenever the Celtics moved the ball for 20 seconds, they always found a wide-open shot.

  • Neither Zaza Pachulia nor Al Horford play big enough. Even worse, Pachulia's offensive moves are incredibly clumsy — he attacked the basket twice and committed two offensive fouls.

  • Williams' stroke is inconsistent.

    Here's a chronological rundown of how ultimately ineffective the Hawks were in the clutch:

  • Bibby buried a critical triple.

  • Smith attacked the hoop with a strong left-handed dribble and executed a savage dunk — but then missed the ensuing free throw.

  • J.J. drove, was fouled, and nailed both freebies.

    The Hawks' Joe Johnson does a ton of things well. (Scott Cunningham / Getty Images)

  • Williams drove, was fouled, and only converted one of two from the stripe.

  • Smith shot an air ball from 16-feet.

  • Horford turned his head on defense, thereby allowing Garnett to grab a lob pass and throw down a hard dunk.

  • J.J. hit a pull-up jumper and went with 2-for-2 from the line when he was fouled on the subsequent possession.

  • Meanwhile, the Hawks were unable to get a stop at the other end. Operating one-on-one from both a low- and a midpost position, Garnett had his way with both Horford and Smith. Why wasn't he doubled?

  • J.J. then missed a relatively easy 15-footer, grabbed the offensive rebound, and had his layup attempt blocked.

  • With the Celtics leading by two and only two seconds left, J.J. was fouled on a drive, made his first free throw, but missed his second. And that was the game.

    The Hawks athleticism and overall feistiness make them a dangerous ballclub. But to move up to the next level, they need Smith to fully regain his chops, a dependable post-up scorer and a quicker point guard.

    However, it bodes well for the future that the Hawks already have many more top-level components than they lack. A good indication of just how mature this team really is will be how/if they recover from this aggravating loss in their next game — at home versus the Warriors on Friday.

    In any event, with astute draft selections, trades, and/or free agent signings, Atlanta is perhaps two years away from becoming one of the league's elite teams.

    Vox Populi

    Who would you rather hang out with, Jerry Garcia or Michael Jordan, and why? — Renato Rodriguez, Portland, OR

    If you have a question or comment for Charley Rosen, submit it below and Charley may just respond.

    Subject:
    Comment/Question:
    Name: 
    Email: 
    Hometown: 

    Over the years, I've attended dozens of concerts that featured Garcia — the Grateful Dead, the Jerry Garcia Band, Old and in the Way and the New Riders of the Purple Sage. I must also confess to having been a Tape Head in my younger days, while continuing to be somewhat interested in bootleg Dead CDs.

    At the same time, I've eyeballed well over a thousand professional basketball games — NBA, CBA, ABA and USBL — as well as many practice sessions thereof.

    While I still consider myself a student of the pro game, my exposure to Garcia's music was strictly from the outside-in. If I can understand the coach's alphabet of Xs and Os, I cannot read music.

    So, then I would love (would have loved) to hang with Captain Trips in order to explore his mind, his music and his personal experiences in the rock/bluegrass subculture.

    But lounging around in His Airness' court isn't exactly a bad alternative.

    Straight Shooting

    All-sports radio stations are generally interested in controversial topics, which is fine by me. However, several stations in New York City have recently stoked the fiery opinions of local basketball fans by putting this question up for grabs: Who was the Knicks' greatest all-time center, Patrick Ewing or Willis Reed?

    But the question in itself is totally absurd.

    Ewing always played hard, and in that sense, he was indeed a warrior. But he was also a choker, one of the most selfish players ever, a reluctant defender and totally clueless about the fine points of the game. His so-called "greatness" is based on his numbers, his longevity in New York and mostly on media hype.

    Reed, on the other hand, was also a warrior. The difference being that he was dynamite in the clutch, played ferocious defense, set stalwart screens, was willing to sacrifice his own stats for the good of the team and was the epitome of heart — the Knicks' captain courageous.

    Anybody who believes that Ewing was superior to Reed is only revealing his own unknowing.

    Travels with Charley

    The first coaching job I ever had was directing the fortunes of the Veraldi Junior High School team in Middletown, N.Y. The young men were a joy to work with — Dickie Fields, Paul Sardella, Jimmy Darling, Jimmy Elia, Emilio Estevez and Jon Peterson, to name only those whose identities my leaky memory can still summon.

    At our initial team meeting held the day before practice was scheduled to commence, I laid down some rules. The one I emphasized the most was the absolute necessity of being on time to every team function.

    "If you're late to practice," I said, "even one minute late, you'll run laps until your tongue drags on the floor. And no excuses of any sort will be tolerated."

    OK. They seemed to be suitably impressed.

    However, everybody was on time for our opening practice except for Peterson. We began our warm-ups and drills, and after about 15 minutes, he made his appearance — all red-faced and sweating and holding a piece of paper for me to read.

    "No excuses," I insisted, waving off the paper. "Start running." Which he did, and with commendable vigor.

    We continued some drills, walked through the basics of our offense and went through a controlled half-court and then full-court scrimmage. It was during the up-and-down scrimmage that something caught my eye — after at least an hour, Peterson was still doggedly running his laps.

    I had completely forgotten about him!

    "OK," I said, with as much nonchalance as I could muster. "That's enough."

    Needless to say, none of the kids was ever late again.

  • Please note by clicking on "add a comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

     advertisement

    FOX SPORTS NBA VIDEO

    Hill: Mavs grab Marion
    FOXSports.com's Randy Hill on the Mavericks' acquisition of Shawn Marion. Find out what Marion's presence will mean for Dallas.
    Artest joins the Lakers
    Hear from Ron Artest as he is introduced in Los Angeles. The Lakers inked the forward to a three year deal hoping he can help them win another ring.

     advertisement

    Statistical Information provided by: STATS LLC
    © 2009 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved.