FOX Sports Video
go to MSN.com
  autos     money     sports     tech     more    
  MSN home  |  Mail  |  My MSN  | 

2008 NFL Draft pick-by-pick analysis

by JOHN CZARNECKI and PETER SCHRAGER, FOXSports.com


add this RSS blog print
Updated: April 27, 2009, 6:13 PM EDT
Comment
With each pick in the first round of the NFL draft, FOXSports.com will provide expert analysis.

Meet the draft experts
JOHN CZARNECKI
FOX NFL Sunday
Czar will analyze each team's draft day war room, the reasoning behind every first-round pick and why teams did or didn't cut a deal.
PETER SCHRAGER
FOXSports.com
Live from New York's Radio City Music Hall, Schrager provides an insider's glimpse of the draft-day doings.

JAKE LONG, OT, MICHIGAN - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: By now, most people around the NFL know that Miami boss Bill Parcells built his retirement home near Saratoga Race Course in upstate New York. Being a horseplayer, the Tuna had the perfect Long entry with the first overall pick. Jake Long was No. 1 and Chris Long was No. 1A. Basically, the Dolphins negotiated potential contracts with both Longs, although the Michigan offensive tackle was their first choice. If Jake didn't take the offer, then Parcells would have selected Howie's oldest son, Chris. Jake Long finally decided to take the Miami offer once his agent Tom Condon checked with the St. Louis Rams to gauge their interest in his client. When the Rams wouldn't guarantee that Jake Long would be their pick at No. 2, Jake opted to take the Miami deal. There's a huge difference between being the first overall pick or the fifth pick (Kansas City undoubtedly would have taken Jake if he'd lasted that long) in the draft because there was no way that Atlanta or Oakland would have drafted him. The Dolphins have so many needs and Parcells apparently believes Jake will be a Pro Bowl player for a long time. He can play both right or left tackle.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: This one was announced on Tuesday. Kind of like Christmas in November. I hung with Long Thursday night at the EA Sports Draft Party. Nothing quite like seeing a kid two nights after signing for $30 million guaranteed. You couldn't wipe the smile off his face. He'll likely start next season, protecting the Dolphins quarterback ... whoever the heck that is. The Radio City Music Hall crowd reaction is similar to a movie theater during a Dane Cook flick: apathetic booing and indifference. And Will Smith's "Welcome To Miami" is now blasting. That's a hit from 1998. Or the last time the Dolphins were respectable.

CHRIS LONG, DE, VIRGINIA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Rams attempted to float the name of LSU defensive tackle Glenn Dorsey in order to get some action from the Falcons and Saints, but couldn't get a serious bite. Virginia's Chris Long was always going to be a top five pick and the Rams went for a clean athlete, knowing that Dorsey does have some injury issues with his right leg. There is no doubt that defensive coordinator Jim Haslett preferred Dorsey, but the front office and head coach Scott Linehan wanted Long and so did new personnel boss Billy Devaney. Rams executives John Shaw and Jay Zygmunt have a 25-year long working relationship with Long's agent Marvin Demoff, a critical component when negotiating a huge first-round contract. When asked by the Ravens to swap first-round picks, the Rams asked the Ravens for their second and fourth-round picks to complete the deal. Based on the new draft point chart that places a value on every pick in the seven rounds, the Rams were a little pricey (2,912 points vs. the value of the second overall pick 2,600). It was surprising that the Rams weren't interested in Jake Long, considering the injury history of former No. 1 pick Orlando Pace. But the Rams must be hopeful that Pace will return after having right shoulder labrum surgery last September. Pace, who signed a $52.8 million extension in 2005, has played in only six games over the past two seasons. Pace has been told he will be ready for full drills by late July when training camp opens.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Rams go with Long, and the upper bowels of Radio City goes wild. I look up and see about 10 20-something guys, all in sport coats, long hair, and huge builds. Long gives them a point. Frat brothers? Who knows? Long erupts from backstage, tosses on the Rams hat, and disappears. He and his enormous bottom jaw will join Adam Carriker on that Rams defensive line — suddenly one of the most promising units in the league.

QB MATT RYAN, BOSTON COLLEGE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Well, new GM Tom Dimitroff had the guts to take a quarterback with his first pick. There had been talk all month that Dimitroff was reluctant to draft a quarterback with the third overall pick because the Falcons have so many needs and with his New England background he knew that Tom Brady was a sixth-round choice. Everyone's reaction is that this was owner Arthur Blank's choice, but don't bet on that. Yes, Blank wanted a quarterback to replace the departed Michael Vick, but Dimitroff and new coach Mike Smith, who obviously wanted defense had to be on board. You can't win in the NFL without a quarterback and Matt Ryan has the arm and the intangibles to be a quality leader. The Falcons didn't hide their interest in Ryan, but a month ago everyone thought Glenn Dorsey would be their first pick.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Michael Vick era is officially a thing of the past, as the Falcons go with Ryan third overall. The hometown Jets crowd goes wild, as they're that much closer to Darren McFadden. Jermaine Dupri's "Welcome to Atlanta" comes on and a few overweight, mustachioed Jets fans start doing shoulder shimmies. Horrible sight, really. Fox colleague Alex Marvez notes, "Matt Ryan hugged Commissioner Goodell. Jake Long did not hug Goodell." You want analysis? You've got analysis.

RB DARREN MCFADDEN, ARKANSAS - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: I guess Michael Bush doesn't look that good in practice. Darren McFadden was always the pick for the Raiders, who said they had enough running backs like Bush, who was injured last year. But McFadden has a chance to be better than Adrian Peterson, last year's rookie of the year, because he's also a super receiver. McFadden also threw for seven touchdowns at Arkansas. I don't think there is a question of his character, either. McFadden has 4.3 speed and can run inside and out. This is the kind of player who can help JaMarcus Russell, last year's No. 1 pick. The Raiders were talking with the Saints about swapping picks and moving to No. 10 overall, but weren't that interested in the compensation. It was surprising that the Raiders passed on Glenn Dorsey because defensive tackle is a definite need and apparently head coach Lane Kiffin won a minor battle because he was not high on selecting Ohio State DE Vernon Gholston with this choice.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: A fantastic clash between two nutjob fan bases here at Radio City, as the Raiders Black Hole faithful goes wild and the Jets Gang Green-ites give a collective look of deep sorrow. I look for the mustachioed Jet fan dancers from a pick earlier, and discover a morbid sight. Their hands are over their faces. Utter disbelief and sadness, like someone just kicked their dogs. McFadden hoists up that #1 silver and black jersey and it just looks right. He joins Justin Fargas, Dominic Rhodes, Lamont Jordan and Michael Bush in the Raiders backfield, where he'll team with JaMarcus Russell for an SEC 1-2 duo in Oakland for years to come. Might as well move their games to Saturday and have Verne Lundquist do the games.

DT GLENN DORSEY, LSU - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Chiefs had their eyes on Chris Long and they were hoping he would fall to them. They also would have been happy with Matt Ryan, but Glenn Dorsey is a great pick, too. Kansas City has so many holes to fill and were reluctant to make a trade with the Saints, who desperately wanted the LSU product. The Chiefs, thanks to their trade with the Vikings, have six picks left in the next 100 choices in order to fill holes at cornerback and the offensive line. There is a chance that they could spend the majority of those choices on both areas, which are huge needs. Dorsey may not be the pass rusher that Warren Sapp was with the Tampa Bay Bucs, but he has the ability to be a dominant inside player. Many teams, though, had listed him as a medical risk and believe he will need surgery on his right leg in the future. It's not a long-term concern; it's just that some teams would like to see him get his leg fixed.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Hard not to love Glenn Dorsey. The All-American, All-Everything looks absolutely thrilled, erupting from the green room with a smile ear to ear. Before Dorsey can even get that Chiefs jersey in his hands, though, the Jets fans are in full "J-E-T-S, Jets, Jets, Jets" mode. The Chiefs took DT's Tank Tyler and Turk McBride in the '07 Draft. Tank and Turk then proceeded to be the most entertaining aspect of HBO's Hard Knocks summer training camp reality program. McBride's coping with roommate Tyler's snoring was the lone highlight of the 2007 Chiefs season. Dorsey, my highest-rated prospect in the entire draft, should help make the '08 campaign a little better for Chiefs fan.

DE VERNON GHOLSTON, OHIO STATE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: There is no question that the Jets wanted Arkansas running back Darren McFadden and only opted to take Ohio State Vernon Gholston, who was the flavor of the month in all the draft previews, because McFadden was off the board. Gholston wowed all the coaches and scouts in a t-shirt and shorts because he is an impressive physical specimen. However, a lot of teams thought Gholston took too many plays off when compared to top defensive picks like Chris Long and Glenn Dorsey. There is no question that Gholston has ability and talent, but he did it for only one year at Ohio State. However, a lot of 3-4 teams believe he's a perfect fit on the outside and there was no question that Jets coach Eric Mangini had him rated highly. Basically, New York got their second favorite player in this draft.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Mixed reaction from the crowd initially, but the "J-E-T-S, Jets, Jets, Jets" chant kicks into high gear once Gholston comes on stage. Our mustachioed friends in the Jets jerseys look mildly pleased, but still seem to be a bit dejected from the McFadden selection. On the bright side, ESPN won't be able to go into "Girl Stuck In a Well" Aaron Rodgers/Brady Quinn mode with their coverage, as all six players invited to New York went 1-6. Billy Joel's "New York State of Mind" plays from above, and the Jets chant switches gears quickly from "J-E-T-S, Jets, Jets, Jets" to "Cheaters, Cheaters, Cheaters." Yep, the Patriots are on the clock. Sure enough, Matt Walsh is currently somewhere in Hawaii, with video footage of the Ravens war room.

DT SEDRICK ELLIS, USC - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: This was supposed to be the Patriots' pick from the 49ers, but it made sense to trade the choice to the Saints, who were desperate for Glenn Dorsey or USC's Sedrick Ellis, the draft's second-best defensive tackle. Ellis fills a big hole with the Saints and don't forget that the Saints acquired Jets inside linebacker Jonathan Vilma during the off-season. New Orleans had to improve its defense and it looks like it has. The Patriots have been zeroing in on Tennessee inside linebacker Jerod Mayo. New Orleans has been burning up the phone lines the past two weeks, but must improve on a second-round pick for New York TE Jeremy Shockey. The Pats picked up an extra third-round pick (78th overall) with this trade while moving down on three spots.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Saints trade up, grab their DT of the future, and the Animals' "House of the Rising Sun" kicks up on the PA system. The one Saints fan in the building, some dude in an undersized Aaron Brooks jersey, pumps his fist furiously and breaks into the "Who Dat" chant. Minutes later, he's still going. He's apparently a huge Sedrick Ellis fan. Who knew?

DE DERRICK HARVEY, FLORIDA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: With Boston College quarterback Matt Ryan gone, the Ravens did the wise thing and traded down with Jacksonville, knowing they have a shot at another quarterback (Chad Henne?) much later in the round. Derrick Harvey, the Florida defensive end, played very well against top pick Jake Long and the Jaguars knew he would never be there when they picked at 26th in the first round. It's not really a risky move for the Jaguars, who believe they are getting close to the Colts and Patriots in the rugged AFC. Believe me, a lot of teams had Harvey rated in the top 10 on their boards, especially those looking for defensive linemen. Jacksonville had to surrender two third-rounders and a fourth-rounder for Harvey, a reasonable price.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Lot of buzz here, as the Jags move up 18 spots to #8, but give up a ton to do so. Harvey's the pick and a few Florida fans in the mezzanine break out the Gators chomp move. Harvey joins fellow Gators star and 2007 first-round pick Reggie Nelson on that D. Toss in Fred Taylor, Mike Peterson, and Jeremy Mincey and that's five Florida guys on one team. Buffalo's playing in Toronto next year, right? Can we get a Jags home game at The Swamp?

LB KEITH RIVERS, USC - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Well, the Bengals still haven't traded disgruntled receiver Chad Johnson. However, coach Marvin Lewis picked a solid outside linebacker in USC's Keith Rivers. Now, Rivers only had three sacks for the Trojans, but he does have super physical upside. Even with getting Odell Thurman back, the Bengals need quality defensive players and Rivers fits a need. For those wanting the Bengals to move Johnson to the Redskins, I still don't see that happening today or tomorrow. Maybe it doesn't make sense to hardcore Cincy fans, but owner Mike Brown won't give in to his talented receiver.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: With Chad Johnson trade rumors rampant here at Radio City, the Bengals just go along with their everyday business, drafting linebacker Keith Rivers with the ninth pick. The "WKRP in Cincinnati" theme is cued up, and the two dejected mustachioed Jets fans from earlier are humming the words passionately. You know what they say — theme songs from mediocre '80s sitcoms starring Loni Andersen are the cure for broken hearts. Meawhile, Johnson is still a Bengal ... for now.

LB JEROD MAYO, TENNESSEE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: I called this pick of Tennessee linebacker Jerod Mayo, the fastest moving player in the draft. I mean, his stock was moving up this week and it was interesting to see that several top mock drafts didn't have him in their top 25 picks. Actually, Mayo was a need pick for the Patriots who have a lot of age at linebacker with Tedy Bruschi, Mike Vrabel and Junior Seau. Mayo is the first linebacker drafted by Bill Belichick in the first round since he's taken over the Patriots. You got to love the Patriots. They got the player they wanted in Mayo and picked up an extra third-round choice. It's a good thing that Commissioner Roger Goodell took away one first-round pick or the best team in football would only have gotten better in this draft.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Jets fans are ruthless. The "cheaters, cheaters, cheaters" chant is now at full blast, rocking Radio City. A teenage girl in a pink Brady jersey is being booed by 40-year-old men in green. You've gotta love the NFL Draft. Meanwhile, the Pats take Jerod Mayo out of Tennessee, giving their roster exactly one linebacker under the age of 65. I had Mayo going 15th to the Lions in my mock draft and got over 100 e-mails killing me for having him going too high. In truth, I didn't have him going high enough.

CB LEODIS MCKELVIN, TROY - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Bills could have gone offense with this pick, but cornerback Leodis McKelvin of Troy makes sense because of head coach Dick Jauron. McKelvin is a heavy hitter and simply needs to improve his ball skills. Also, think of the Patriots in this division. The Bills have to defend Tom Brady & Randy Moss and McKelvin should help in that area. McKelvin may surprise some because of all the talk about Dominique Rogers-Cromartie, but McKelvin has fewer holes. The draft isn't very sexy right now because teams will be taking offensive linemen and some cornerbacks. It will become fun again when some quarterbacks and receivers are taken. Remember, it's a bad year for both positions.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Things worked out well for Buffalo, as the Bills got the top cornerback in the draft in McKelvin. No Bills fans in sight. No Troy fans in sight. But plenty of Bob Marley fans. "Buffalo Soldier" is played and the whole place breaks out in a calming hum. After the hatred being spewed during the Patriots pick, it's nice to just "chill" out with some Marley for a bit. Koom Bay Ah.

OT RYAN CLADY, BOISE STATE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Broncos just became the first NFL team to ever take a Boise State player in the first round. Offensive tackle Ryan Clady is coming to protect quarterback Jay Cutler. Clady will probably play on the right side as a rookie, but what this young man has is great feet. His body is a little soft and he posted a very low Wonderlic score, but Clady does have tremendous athletic skills and the Broncos love athletic offensive linemen. Not a risky pick because some mock drafts had the Chiefs picking him fifth overall — although that was never going to happen — but he does have better left tackle technique right now than No. 1 pick Jake Long.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Clady slips to the Broncos, who gladly scoop up the All-American at 12th overall. John Denver's "Rocky Mountain High" plays immediately after "Buffalo Soldier" and it's a full-on singers and songwriters afternoon at Radio City. What's next? James Taylor doing "Carolina on My Mind"? Umm ... yes, actually, yes it is. The Clady pick gets mixed reactions from the few Broncos fans in the crowd. One guy's got a Brian Griese jersey on. Brian Griese, huh? Apparently, his Tommy Maddox one was in the wash.

RB JONATHAN STEWART, OREGON - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Panthers were thinking quarterback at this position, but they always loved Oregon running back Jonathan Stewart, a guy who should play immediately alongside DeAngelo Williams. From a fan perspective, running back doesn't appear to be a need for the Panthers, who just had defensive end Mike Rucker retire. But Stewart was the second-rated running back in the draft behind Darren McFadden. The Panthers considered trading up for Matt Ryan, but the price was too steep. This pick proves how smart the Jaguars were to move ahead of the Panthers in order to select Derrick Harvey.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: After a little James Taylor to make this place even more eerily mellow, the Panthers grab Jonathan Stewart out of Oregon. Though the crowd is mildly surprised by this selection, I'm pretty much floored. I had Stewart going 36th to the Jets in my latest mock draft, a good 24 picks later. Stewart over Rashard Mendenhall is surprising; a running back over an offensive lineman here is shocking. Meanwhile, FOX colleague Adam Schein texts me "Told you he was a first rounder." Good for you, Adam. Good for you. I'll now take the next 10 minutes to wipe the egg off of my face.

OT CHRIS WILLIAMS, VANDERBILT - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Bears may have been tempted to replace departed receiver Bernard Berrian, but Vanderbilt offensive tackle Chris Williams could start at left tackle and allow them to move John Tait to right tackle. I told you there was going to be a run on offensive linemen, probably the first round's strongest position. Williams played against very athletic defenders in the SEC and held his own. His stock went up with a very impressive Senior Bowl, where he dominated many a pass rusher. This is a solid pick for the Bears, who needed a smart and tough offensive lineman. Funny, but the Bears weren't really interested in a quarterback with this pick. To them, they have bigger issues trying to settle a contract hassle with Chicago's favorite player, Brian Urlacher.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Bears need pretty much everything on offense this draft, and they start it off by grabbing offensive tackle Chris Williams out of Vanderbilt. Williams is the first All-SEC lineman out of Vandy since Will Wofford in 1984. Go share that factoid at your water cooler on Monday morning. You'll look really cool, I swear. The Bears fans here do what I call "The D'Brickashaw Ferguson." What's that? It's a golf clap and a point to the head, as in "Smart Pick," made famous by the Jets fans' reaction to Ferguson's selection in 2006. The highlights of Williams on the big screen are of a giant man pushing a blocking dummy. Hard to get real excited about that. So you do "The D'Brickashaw Ferguson," and nod. Sage-like.

OG BRANDEN ALBERT, VIRGINIA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Lions made a smart trade here, giving their pick to the Chiefs, who really need Virginia's Branden Albert. This young man has the flexibility to play guard and tackle, although he is a better guard and is tremendous in open space. Next to his son, Howie Long most loved Albert's ability to run out and block people in the open field. The Chiefs really need offensive linemen and the Lions don't. This trade also gives the Chiefs some ammunition to pick some cornerbacks later in the draft. It's amazing to think that Albert could develop into the best offensive lineman in this draft. How about that? Kansas City fans may not like the record, but they should love Carl Peterson's first two picks in the draft. Larry Johnson should love this pick, too.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Chiefs move up a few picks and grab Branden Albert, a guy whose stock pretty much did the exact opposite of Bear Stearns' in the month of March. Rising, rising, and rising — Chris Long's college teammate goes to K.C., where he'll look to bring back some of the glory on the KC O-Line left by the recent retirements of Willy Roaf and Will Shields. Somewhere, Larry Johnson and Brody Croyle just took enormous sighs of relief. Naturally, a guy in a Dwayne Bowe jersey a few rows up gives a 10/10 "The D'Brickashaw Ferguson." Full nod and fist pump. Linemen!

CB DOMINIQUE RODGERS-CROMARTIE, TENNESSEE ST. - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: All week the word was that the Cardinals wanted either a cornerback or a running back with this pick and they got their man in Tennessee State's Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, whom they had rated as a top corner on their draft board. This pick proves, too, that Illinois RB Rashard Mendenhall is sliding. Cromartie has a big upside; he's fast and quick and simply needs to learn how to refine those skills on the NFL level. A few thought that the Cardinals may take an offensive lineman, but secondary was a need.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Cards grab Antonio Cromartie's cousin, Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, out of Tennessee State. Cromartie had a pretty great pre-draft season, dominating the Senior Bowl, killing it at the combine, and then blowing everyone's mind at his Pro Day. He'll now go to Arizona, where he'll join recent draft picks Matt Leinart, Larry Fitzgerald, and Levi Brown in re-building the Cards. Somewhere, Leinart's pumping his fist in approval ... or pumping a keg. One or the other.

OT GOSDER CHERILUS, BOSTON COLLEGE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE:Matt Millen's pick of Boston College right tackle Gosder Cherilus will be questioned because he traded with Kansas City and gave them Branden Albert. Gosder does have a strong punch, but he doesn't look like a left tackle in the NFL. The Steelers really liked him. This kid is tough; he simply needs to be coached and elevate his game-day play. There is a lot of upside to Cherilus. Don't look for Millen to be trading receiver Roy Williams today or any day in the future. The Lions can't get enough value for Williams, who really was one of Millen's best picks ever. Millen did pick up an extra third round pick when he traded with KC.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: In a shocking development, Matt Millen takes a position other than wide receiver in the first round. The Lions take Gosder Cherilus, a 6-6, 305 pound lineman from B.C. Several Lions fans in the house, including one guy in a Joey Harrington jersey who is going wild. Huge Cherilus fan, apparently. The guy next to him has a Mike Williams jersey on. They try to slap five and kind of mess up the timing. No surprise there.

QB JOE FLACCO, DELAWARE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: I can't believe that the Ravens thought they had to make another trade in order to draft Delaware quarterback Joe Flacco. I guess I was fooled with all the talk about Michigan QB Chad Henne to Baltimore. A couple of months ago, Miami insiders thought that Bill Parcells would be drafting Flacco. This kid played in a spread offense, but did play under center enough in order to see how he will adjust to the NFL game. There is no question that quarterback was a need for the Ravens and they ended up with their second-best player at the position. I think it is difficult to say that Flacco will be better than Matt Ryan right now, but he does have an arm and good mobility. I don't see new head coach John Harbaugh starting Flacco over Kyle Boller in September.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: With John Harbaugh comes a new offensive scheme and apparently a new quarterback in Baltimore. It's Mr. Kaiser Soze himself, Joe Flacco. A 6-7 beast out of Delaware, no one in this room had even heard of Flacco five months ago. He's really tall, though! The few Ravens fans in the building are ecstatic, jumping up and down and hugging. Hugging over Joe Flacco? Really? They loved his work in the James Madison game this year. Or was it against New Hampshire? Either way, they're pumped.

OT JEFF OTAH, PITTSBURGH - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Panthers traded with the Eagles in order to select Pitt offensive tackle Jeff Otah, who was considered a little soft by some teams. However, he was a top 15 player on the Carolina board and that's why they made the move. The Panthers have a need on the offensive line and Otah is a huge kid with a lot of strength. There was some talk that Otah doesn't like football that much and that the draft was a means to an end, so he will be an interesting player to watch in the future. Obviously, the Panthers don't view him that way or they would have never made such a trade. The Panthers gave up a lot for Otah, including next year's first-round pick. A heavy price for a player with some question marks.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: For the third straight year, the Eagles fans get worked up in a frenzy over the Rocky tune "Gonna Fly Now," only to have their home team trade the pick away at the last second. It's become a yearly tradition. Two guys in McNabb jerseys are sweating. Full on sweat. That dancing they were doing was the first physical activity they've done in years. The Panthers move up and get Jeff Otah, a giant mauling offensive tackle. With Stewart and Otah, the offense should be upgraded substantially down in Carolina. There are no Carolina Panthers fans in the building. Not one. I just scoured the entire place and can't find a soul. C'mon Panthers fans, make the trip next year! Give us something. Meanwhile, the Eagles fans are all still sweating. Profusely.

CB AQIB TALIB, KANSAS - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Bucs were never going to take a receiver with the first pick. They chose Kansas cornerback Aqib Talib, who does have some off-the-field issues, but also has tremendous skills. Talib is an interesting pick because many teams didn't see him as a Cover Two cornerback like Ronde Barber, but more as a man-to-man cover cornerback. A lot of teams rated Talib as a top-10 talent, but were worried about his personality and character. But Talib isn't a risk with the 20th pick because he's not going to get top-10 money. A solid player who can also help in the return game.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: An unnamed middle-aged member of the media sitting nearby waits until everyone's quit talking, takes a deep breath, and comments, "The Marijuana Man!" A pack of fellow middle-aged members of the media surrounding him laugh uproariously in unison. Hilarious! This is the comedy you're missing at Radio City, folks. Hey, failed drug tests or not, Talib was fantastic his entire career in Lawrence, capping it off with an All-American 2007 campaign in which the Jayhawks won the Orange Bowl. I'm a huge Talib guy. Ronde Barber can't play forever. This is a solid pick. I just did "The D'Brickashaw Ferguson" move.

OT SAM BAKER, USC - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Redskins traded their 21st pick to the Falcons for USC offensive lineman Sam Baker, who was once rated a top-15 player. Some teams had him at the top of the second round in this draft and others feel his arms are too short to play left tackle. Baker, though, is big and strong enough to play either guard or right tackle. Obviously, the Falcons were nervous about not being able to protect No. 1 pick Matt Ryan and that's why they made the deal with the Redskins. Give the Falcons credit for going offense when everyone thought they would use the top of the draft for defensive players. Baker does have upside and his attitude and approach will never be questioned.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Falcons take the three-time All-American in Baker and the few Falcons fans here respond with approving claps. A guy is wearing a Michael Vick jersey. That's some statement. Do PETA members throw crap at you as you walk down the street? And if you're wearing a Vick jersey now, what other jerseys do you own in that closet back home? A Rae Carruth? A Lawrence Phillips? Odell Thurman? Regardless, it's a bold wardrobe move. One that Joan Rivers would not approve of.

RB FELIX JONES, ARKANSAS - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Cowboys used the first of their two first-round picks on Arkansas running back Felix Jones. Remember, all the rumors about owner Jerry Jones trying to work a trade to get Darren McFadden? Well, such a move would have cost too much. Felix Jones is a solid running back and Jerry Jones still gets a Razorback on his roster, which was always the goal, right? Jones may not be an every-down running back, but Jones could be a perfect complement to Marion Barber, one of the toughest runners in the NFL. Now, Jones isn't as talented as McFadden, but when scouts visited Arkansas they came away impressed with Felix Jones and rated him awfully close to McFadden. Jones is light, but he does have great north-south explosion.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: In the "Great Moments in NFL Draft Fan Chant History" annals of the NFL Hall of Fame, they'll capture the scene I just witnessed here at Radio City: Three Cowboys fans, seated side by side by side, chanting "Dallas Cowboys; Dallas Cowboys; Dallas Cowboys," and in between every "Dallas Cowboys" three very clever Giants fans seated directly behind them yell in unison the word "SUCK!" This goes on at least a dozen times. A dozen! "Dallas Cowboys" ... "Suck!" ... "Dallas Cowboys" ... "Suck!" Over and over again. My brain hurts from watching this. But the Dallas fans seem happy with the Felix Jones pick. They get the lightning to Marion Barber's thunder; the same role Jones played for McFadden at Arkansas.

RB RASHARD MENDENHALL, ILLINOIS - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Next to offensive linemen, I thought running back was the next quality position in this draft. The Steelers took Illinois back Rashard Mendenhall, who can catch and also run out of a spread formation. Mendenhall slipped today because some teams considered him a one-season wonder at Illinois although Mel Kiper had him rated 10th overall in this draft. The Steelers didn't have a specific need and they simply went with the best available player. Mendenhall has enough ability to give Willie Parker a rest and that's what all great backs need. Parker may not like this choice, buy Mendenhall has the moves and the hands to be successful in the NFL.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Steelers fans were chanting "Mendenhall ... Mendenhall" and they got the man they wanted. The Terrible Towels are out, and being waved fanatically. As a thousand Steelers fans will tell you, Najeh Davenport just wasn't ready to carry the load once Willie Parker went down with injury last year. Mendenhall, who I thought would be a top 15 pick, goes 23 to Pittsburgh. In the crowd, I just spotted a woman with a Steelers helmet, a Hines Ward jersey, and actual shoulder pads on ... and I didn't even flinch at the sight. Standard.

RB CHRIS JOHNSON, EAST CAROLINA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Well, East Carolina running back Chris Johnson will replace Pacman Jones in the return game. Johnson ran a 4.28 40-yard dash at the NFL Combine and this pick had to be all about speed. The Titans spent two high picks on running backs in recent years, so I have to wonder why the position was such a need. LenDale White is supposed to be the main runner, but don't forget that Tennessee spent a second-round pick on Chris Henry of Arizona last year. Many teams had Johnson in the second round. I just think the Titans have more pressing needs than running back. This pick, though, gives you an idea what teams think of this year's receivers.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Let's give it up for the NFL's deejay here at Radio City. His musical selections have been fabulous all afternoon. The choice for the Titans pick? Arrested Development's "Tennessee." What's Arrested Development up to now? Weddings? Bar Mitzvahs? When the song drags out, the Titans take Chris Johnson, the 4.2 40 speed demon out of East Carolina. He'll join LenDale White and Chris Henry in the Tennessee backfield. At receiver for the Titans? John Doe 1, John Doe 2, and John Doe 3. Can the guys from Arrested Development catch a football? Someone should ask.

DB MIKE JENKINS, SOUTH FLORIDA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Seattle traded the 25th overall pick in the round to the Cowboys, who used the selection on South Florida cornerback Mike Jenkins. Dallas was supposed to pick 28th in the round, but they were worried about the Chargers taking Jenkins. Jerry Jones didn't want to take a chance because he wanted to leave the first round with a running back and a cornerback. Jones really didn't want to draft a receiver and none have been taken in the first 25 picks. The Cowboys gave Seattle a fifth and a seventh round pick to move three spots; good value, I think. Remember, Dallas CB Terence Newman is entering the last year of his contract.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: "Dallas Cowboys" ... "Dallas Cowboys" ... No suck? I guess the Giants fans have had a change of heart since the 22nd pick overall. Good. I hated seeing the Dallas and New York fans not getting along. Jenkins is the pick, a 2007 All-American out of South Florida. A lethal return man — just like Felix Jones — Dallas now has two guys who can take back kicks and punts. Somewhere, Miles Austin sheds a tear. The deejay goes to the "Dallas" theme music. Patrick Duffy's nowhere to be found.

OT DUANE BROWN, VIRGINIA TECH - Profile
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Virginia Tech Duane Brown was considered a second-rounder, but Houston was running out of options and Brown does have very good feet and athletic ability. Brown played tight end at one time and he also has the long arms necessary to play left tackle. Brown has a great chance to be a starter for the Texans, who needed linemen on both sides of the ball. They kept trading down once they missed out on Chris Williams of Vanderbilt.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Texans grab Duane Brown, the tackle out of Virginia Tech. Though there aren't many Texans fans in the house, there are a few folks in Virginia Tech jerseys. They're doing the "D'Brickashaw Ferguson" move and they're not even Houston fans. Great highlights of Duane Brown beating up on tackling dummies on the big screen. The tackling dummies don't even put up a fight.

CB ANTOINE CASON, ARIZONA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Chargers GM A.J. Smith had Arizona cornerback Antoine Cason circled as his potential pick weeks ago. Cason has excellent ball skills and should help immediately as a nickel back. San Diego doesn't have many needs although there remain injury concerns with certain star players. LaDainian Tomlinson's knee still doesn't feel right and tight end Antonio Gates (toe) may not be ready for training camp. Cason lost his grandfather, Rambo, to cancer in February and the young man launched a "Cason Cares" fundraiser to deal with the loss. Cason opted to return for his senior season at Arizona and there is little doubt about his character. A solid pick by the Chargers and a player who should help in the secondary.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Great crew of Chargers fans near the front of Radio City. One is wearing an Antonio Gates jersey, while the other is in what appears to be a Seau one. Both seem quite content with the Cason pick, even hugging afterwards. Does Antoine Cason have any idea that two Chargers fans just HUGGED over his selection? Cason joins recent Day One draft picks Antonio Cromartie and Eric Weddle in what should be a pretty lethal defensive backfield for years to come.

DE LAWRENCE JACKSON, USC - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Seattle took the fourth USC player — DE Lawrence Jackson — with their first-round pick. Jackson had 17 tackles behind the line of scrimmage in 2007, the most since Kenechi Udeze had 26 in 2003. The Seahawks were talking about taking a quarterback at one time with this pick, but backed off that decision. This may be Mike Holmgren's last draft in Seattle, but you can bet that Jim Mora has more influence over GM Tim Ruskell. Jackson is definitely an outside player, whereas the Seahawks have more of a need at defensive tackle. Like most first rounds, the bottom of the round tends to disintegrate. This is not a bad pick, but most teams had him in the second round.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: After a nice Pearl Jam/Nirvana medley, the Seahawks grab Lawrence Jackson, the sack machine out of USC. Phillip Merling's groin injury must be a lot worse than publicized, as everyone's Top 20 pick now looks to have fallen out of the first round. In a momentary slip up to what was a fantastic overall performance, the deejay plays "Bittersweet Symphony" by The Verve. A band from Wigan, England. You figure it out. Maybe Paul Allen really digs them? Probably not.

DT KENTWAN BALLMER, NORTH CAROLINA - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The 49ers love coaching the Senior Bowl and they may have found another gem in North Carolina defensive tackle Kentwan Balmer. I believe this position is a need for the 49ers, who are improving against the run but need more consistency. Balmer played both defensive tackle positions in college and also lined up at right defensive end. He finished with only seven career sacks, but did have 59 solo tackles and 9½ tackles for losses in his senior season. San Francisco, like every other team, had no interest in Cal receiver DeSean Jackson in the first round.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Well, I've seen it all. A guy in a #10 Giants jersey with the name "DALLASSUCKS" on the back has somehow gotten into the media section of Radio City and is fully leading "Dallas Sucks" chants. That's a lot of work, making that jersey. What's the process there? You come up with the idea, go on NFL.com, and pay $90 for it? Then slap five with Giants fans at tailgates every Sunday? And get spit on by Dallas fans at sports bars? I guess so. Hey, to each his own. The Niners go with Balmer, a run-stuffing DT from North Carolina. The crowd doesn't seem very interested in the selection.

TE DUSTIN KELLER, PURDUE - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: The Jets needed to leave this round with a playmaker and Purdue tight end Dustin Keller was an interesting pick because many thought the Giants wanted to take him at No. 31. Keller is definitely more of a receiver than a blocker. I preferred USC's Fred Davis, but this fifth-year senior has been favorably compared to Indy's Dallas Clark. Keller had seven catches for 101 yards against Ohio State, which means he has enough quickness and speed to take on quality competition. Keller was a wide receiver in high school. The Jets only had to give the Packers a fourth-round pick to move into this spot and that's good value, especially if they messed with the Giants' plans.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: The Jets trade up and a "Devin ... Thomas" chant gets going. Instead, the Jets go with Dustin Keller out of Purdue. The crowd reaction is quite similar to the one when New York took Kyle Brady over Warren Sapp and J.J. Stokes in the 1995 Draft. Shock. Awe. Sadness. In truth, they'll come to like Keller, a great target for Kellen Clemens and Chad Pennington over the middle.

FS KENNY PHILLIPS, MIAMI - Profile |
CZAR'S FRONT OFFICE TAKE: Well, Jeremy Shockey remains a Giant and that's a good thing for New York fans and the team. I think GM Jerry Reese made another smart move here with Hurricane safety Kenny Phillips, who was definitely the only safety considered by most teams to have first-round talent. Phillips has enough speed to play cornerback, plus he's a very good tackler. Remember, last year every one of Reese's draft picks made the roster and contributed down the stretch to their Super Bowl run. For the last pick in the round, Phillips was a worthy talent, plus he brings some attitude to the clubhouse. Reese wanted more than a second-round pick for Shockey from the Saints. Teams looking for a safety had Phillips rated in the bottom third of the first round.

SCHRAGER ON THE SCENE: Commissioner Goodell refers to the Giants as "The Super Bowl Champion Giants" and Radio City goes nuts. A subtle reminder, that wow, yes, the Giants actually won the Super Bowl in February. Meanwhile, "DALLASSUCKS" jersey guy has CHANGED into a new jersey — a white #44 Ahmad Bradshaw jersey. He's very proud of this wardrobe adjustment and pulls his jersey repeatedly, waving it in his section's face. The G-Men address their void at safety, grabbing Kenny Phillips out of Miami. Jesse Armstead, Sinorice Moss, Jeremy Shockey ... the Giants have a long history with guys from the U.

Please note by clicking on "add a comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

 advertisement

FOX SPORTS NFL Draft VIDEO

Marvez: Draft Day 1 recap
FOXSports.com senior NFL writer Alex Marvez recaps the first day of the NFL Draft. Find out what moves made headlines and more.
On the Clock: Eagles
The Eagles have needed a running back for years now. Could this be the year Philly takes a runner with their first pick?

 advertisement

Statistical Information provided by: STATS LLC
© 2009 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved.