FOX Sports Video
go to MSN.com
  autos     money     sports     tech     more    
  MSN home  |  Mail  |  My MSN  | 

Second guesses: Roethlisberger needs a break

by John Czarnecki

John Czarnecki has been the editorial consultant for FOX NFL Sunday since its 1994 inception. This season marks Czarnecki's 32nd year covering the NFL. He is one of 44 selectors to the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

add this RSS blog print
Updated: November 10, 2008, 2:56 AM EST
115 comments
Maybe Ben Roethlisberger needs a rest. He has thrown eight interceptions in his last 88 pass attempts, and not much has been working for him lately. It's hard to bench a franchise quarterback, but maybe he needs to take some time off.

I know this sounds crazy because he has February and March and April and May to lie on a beach or simply stay in bed and relax while his throwing shoulder mends. But things are not going right for Big Ben right now. He had four more passes intercepted Sunday. He's struggling and forcing throws and basically having a lot of bad luck.

The Steelers are still a very good team, but they lost Sunday because the Colts had a better quarterback in Peyton Manning. He fired three touchdown passes to Ben's none and didn't have an interception, either.

I say give Byron Leftwich a chance against the Chargers next Sunday and see if it feels right. Coaches make changes all the time with other positions; quarterback, though, has become very sacred. The Steelers have made a long-term financial commitment to Roethlisberger. That isn't going to change. The two are stuck with each other. But right now, the Steelers need something different at the position.

It's a short-term fix and definitely nothing permanent. And I bet if Coach Mike Tomlin took a vote in the locker room, Leftwich would win much like Obama did last Tuesday.

What did Chiefs have to lose?

Basically, Chiefs Coach Herm Edwards went all in. He pushed his chips to the center of the table, hoping to catch the winner in a matter of seconds. There was really no time to review the decision. It was all guts. It was all instincts. Yes, we can second-guess the decision to go for the win, to call for a 2-point pass with seconds left, but when you have won only one game all season, what really are your options?

I asked Jimmy Johnson what he would have done.

"If I was coaching a team like the Chiefs, I would have went for it, too," Johnson replied.

It would have been a super high had Tyler Thigpen been able to complete his 2-point throw. He had two receivers to his right side as he rolled in their direction, but with a Charger in his face, closing fast. He had to hurry his throw and it was off target. Tight end Tony Gonzalez, who had just caught his second touchdown of the day, was a couple yards away from the errant pass. He had just caught his second score on a fourth-down play.

The Chiefs played a gutsy game. But the only people rejoicing were the Chargers and head coach Norv Turner. Even with the switch to Ron Rivera as defensive coordinator, the Chargers simply don't resemble their customary, explosive selves. LaDainian Tomlinson never seems to find his fourth gear anymore and Philip Rivers continues to throw interceptions in the end zone after driving the offense the length of the field.

Finally, if there was one Chief to second-guess it was punter Dustin Colquitt, who also serves as the holder. He botched a snap earlier in the game and panicked. He still had time to collect himself and put the ball down for kicker Connor Barth. But, no, he got up and had no where to go with the ball.

Had Colquitt kept his cool, the extra point might have been good and Herm Edwards wouldn't have had to gamble and go for two at the end. Funny twist to another tough-luck loss for the Chiefs. At least Edwards and the Chiefs can console themselves in knowing they did the right thing in sticking with Thigpen and turning their back on Daunte Culpepper.

Fisher gets this vote

This next debate starts by admitting that I like Falcons coach Mike Smith and I am thoroughly impressed with how he's turned Arthur Blank's franchise around. It is one of the most amazing storylines of this NFL season. But if you had to vote for Coach of the Year right now, should Smith be a landslide winner? Is he doing a better job than John Harbaugh, another first-year head coach, in Baltimore?

Like Smitty, Harbaugh is 6-3 and also is playing with a rookie quarterback in Joe Flacco, a kid not as highly rated as Matt Ryan. You would think both men are worthy candidates. Heck, they are probably the favorites with most of the AP voters.

But right now I would vote for Tennessee coach Jeff Fisher. His Titans are the only unbeaten team and he is winning with Kerry Collins, a venerable backup who doesn't exactly remind anyone of Tom Brady.

But before turning to Collins, Fisher had to basically bench Vince Young, a former first-round pick earning millions of dollars. He had to keep his team together while telling the so-called future of the franchise to heal up and take a seat. And take a seat for probably the rest of the season.

Sometimes the best decision any coach makes comes on a weekday and not on game day. Fisher made the right call, moving on without his former Rookie of the Year. It was a tough one. It helped that he also knew most of his locker room believed he was making the right call. But does anyone know how hard it is to go unbeaten without your starting quarterback, the guy you prepared with all summer to be your leader?

Often, when voting for awards, it becomes fashionable to vote for the newcomer rather than someone like Fisher who has proven once again that he remains among the game's top three or four coaches in the last decade.

Parcells had the right idea

I wanted to second-guess Bill Parcells' decision to leave the Cowboys and try something new in Miami. He went to run former owner Wayne Huizenga's franchise for a tidy $4 million a season. It seemed like a great semi-retirement job with good pay. All he had to do was pick the head coach and the general manager. Not surprisingly, he picked two men he groomed with the Cowboys, Tony Sparano and Jeff Ireland. They are both no-nonsense leaders like Parcells was when he roamed the sidelines.

But if we call the Falcons a major surprise, the Dolphins are in the same league. They have won five games and still have a playoff chance, having already beaten the Patriots and Bills. Who knows where they would be without Chad Pennington? They have the Packers and Jets to thank for that.

But they are alive because Sparano had the guts to try something different with two of his best players, running backs Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams. They shocked the Patriots and the NFL with a wildcat formation, basically a direct snap to a running back while the quarterback splits out wide like a receiver.

You see everyone doing it now. The Eagles did it Sunday night with DeSean Jackson. Penn State used the formation on Saturday against Iowa. I have counted six other NFL teams employing some version of Miami's wildcat this season.

The NFL is the greatest copycat league in America. And what's amazing to me is that the formation is still clicking for the Dolphins. Miami has scored 21 offensive touchdowns this season and eight of them have come from the wildcat formation. In their close win over a pesky Seattle team, the Dolphins scored twice from the wildcat and their other touchdown, a long Pennington pass to Ted Ginn, came off a flea flicker. The Dolphins are not NFL traditionalists, but they are finding a way to win and that's all that counts.

Some advice for the Lions

We heard that for his physical last week Daunte Culpepper weighed around 280 pounds. Culpepper has always been a big quarterback, much like JaMarcus Russell in Oakland. He probably is better at 260 pounds, but what do you want from a former Pro Bowler who has been coaching PeeWee football the past two months?

Culpepper looked sluggish at times and also accurate on one particular possession. The Lions did a smart thing, rotating Culpepper and Drew Stanton, who's quicker and stronger right now. Plus, Stanton deserved to get some playing time.

Right now, the Lions have no answers and also no solutions. They have lost 10 straight games and 16 of their last 17. They were so desperate for a win against Green Bay earlier in the season that former GM Matt Millen attempted to pick Brett Favre's brain for clues and tips about the Packers' offense while one of his defensive coaches listened in.

Millen is gone and eventually the coaches will be, too. I don't know if there is a quick fix in Detroit, but there is really only one man the Ford Family should consider: New England's Scott Pioli. He's the best personnel man out there who is young enough to consider starting anew.

Like William Clay Ford did with Millen, he has to give him total control and the keys to his facility. Ford has to at least try. And there's a good example of why the move may actually work — just look at the job Tom Dimitroff has done as a first-year GM with the Falcons. A year ago, Dimitroff was Pioli's top college scout.

Please note by clicking on "add a comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Use and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator.

Member Comments


Add your comment
No comments yet.

Fierceblues-Finally some good dialogue in the comments section and not some still sobbing Seahawk fan ranting about how they should have won a few years back. <br /><br />I agree Ben isn't playing up to par, but comments made to the media showed that he is a true leader and that he is willing to take full responsibility for the interceptions. Play back the game and you'll see Holmes stop in the middle of a timing route (yes, Ben was being pressured and Holmes may have felt he needed to break his route to help out), another was a lucky break for the Colts (a tipped pass), and yet another was off a last second desperation toss up in the end zone. Hardly a need to lynch mob the guy. Coming off a very emotional, high energy Monday night game, his injuries (which I have clearly stated he should have been rested), and the interceptions I talked about, the man is still a good QB.<br /><br />As far as this article goes, can I get paid for providing most of the content? Its the second in a row which states the obvious, except with a blind view regarding why Ben has been intercepted. A bit of a reach for a second guess article. Hell, Steeler fans "guessed" all this prior to the game. A little more research and less media hype "lynch-mobbing" would be nice.

MDSteelersfanMDSteelersfan
(Report inappropriate content)

Hey Steelerin, you are absolutely right. Couldn't have said it any better. The one thing you said is that we don't have a stellar running game, not even close. Willie Parker is mediocre at best. Anybody want me to explain myself, I will. So many steeler fans think he's great. That's a joke. He's not even close.

pitty1pitty1
(Report inappropriate content)

I have a comment for Jledhead. I am a diehard steelers fan, but if you think were going back to the super bowl, anytime soon, think again. The only way is if the defense is absolutely perfect, and I don't believe they are capable of getting us their by themselves. Our o-line, quarterback and running back are not good enuff, bottom line. Hope I am prooven wrong.

pitty1pitty1
(Report inappropriate content)

Here's a fact from last game..... Every, and I mean every first down was a running play. The Colts, as any team would, picked up on that and put 8 in the box. The comment made earlier about Arians is 100% correct, he needs to go. <br />As far as Ben, he is not the same QB. Chris Carter made the comment on the pre game that Bens first couple years were spent running the ball 75% of the time, then passing for highlight reels. It's true. Now that they don't have a stellar running game, he is not the type of QB to throw the ball 30 times a game. He is a QB that flourishes off of momentum, even then he is not an accurate passer, but he makes plays. Byron gives them the best chance to win NOW. Long term I still believe Ben is the man, but he isn't for now.

SteelerinWISteelerinWI
(Report inappropriate content)

I agree Arians is just useless and should be gone. As I said before Roethlisberger ain't gonna take you to another superbowl at this point in time if ever. As far as that colts fan, bounty hunter is right, you don't put your o-line under the bus. Lose like a man. Ben's line is hideous but do you see him hang them out to dry, No, he is a stand up guy who usually blames himself regardless of how **** his line is. Manning should realize that and if he didn't have the line he has had for all these years, he would be dead by now literally. He couldn't withstand half the beating Ben takes. Manning runs like a little girl. All he knows how to do is stand in the pocket for 10 minutes and throw. Anybody professional qb could do that with that kind of time.

pitty1pitty1
(Report inappropriate content)

True...but I would have liked "Smiley" Ward to ask management to draft a QB that doesn't throw hideous picks. <br />.....of course don't ask for this after season ending loss.

bostfanbostfan
(Report inappropriate content)

bostfan, Ben may very well have said that, but it wasn't after a season ending loss!

bountyhunter236bountyhunter236
(Report inappropriate content)

bmm, you're correct, Leftwich is not the total answer but he needs to be starting for the next couple of weeks. Part of Ben's problems are Ben but the biggest part of his problem id that idiot Arians run, run, put your QB in third and long. That guy needs to be run out of town.

bountyhunter236bountyhunter236
(Report inappropriate content)

gocolts4, BS he used those exact words, not sugar coated the way you make them out to be. What kind of a team player and qurterback throws his entire O line under the bus afier a critical loss? A selfish self centered little p r i c k .

bountyhunter236bountyhunter236
(Report inappropriate content)

gocolts: I don't think anyone is suggesting Leftwich is the answer long-term. However, he should be adequate for a week or two to let Big Ben rest the shoulder.

bmm0321bmm0321
(Report inappropriate content)

bountyhunter<br />If you are going to put quotation marks around the words you attribute to Manning, you should try to be accurate. He said that they needed to get their protection figured out. He later included himself, because he calls the plays. It was three years ago. Obviously, his teammates let it go a long time ago, so you might want to give it a try, as well. Speaking of classless... You can tell you're a fan if you're convinced Leftwich is the answer.

gocolts4gocolts4
(Report inappropriate content)

Double-07....I'm trying to help Steeler fans come to grips with Rottenburger. He is not the great QB people make him out to be. His decisions are terrible. You said it yourself Byron didn't put Steeler D in bad situation. That's all Ben has to do. That throw in Skins game (a gift to Rogers) and throwing INT when your up 24-20 late in 4th Qtr are but just 2 examples. I have seen Ben doing this since the 2nd half of rookie season.

bostfanbostfan
(Report inappropriate content)

I take that back......Eli is better than Ben. much better.

OAKTOWN77OAKTOWN77
(Report inappropriate content)

As a die hard steelers fan I realize that our teams best option (long term) at qb is big ben. He is also our best option to win another super bowl. This could be the year we go back to the super bowl, however much like in 05 big ben needs a game or two of rest. His shoulder is clearly bothering him more then he has lead on. He has been throwing way to many interceptions and has had a couple of stupid sacks where he dropped the football. Now coach Ariens plays aren't helping either. If Ben is hurt and the team still wants to play him we should be running short dink and dunk routes not trying to throw the ball 40 plus yards every 5th play. On our last drive on sunday the one that reminded me of 95 afc championship game only the roles were reversed. The refs cost us a good 5 seconds there not that 5 seconds would of helped but you never know. This is the nfl and you will win some and lose some however if ben keeps throwing stupid passes and interceptions every 10th pass we are going to be losing more then we are winning. Let byron start this week rest big ben we can still win our division just beat the bengals, browns, and the old browns one more time and its done. With a win over New England we should end up with the number 2 spot in the playoffs, and a great shot at the super bowl.

jledhead01jledhead01
(Report inappropriate content)

bostfan<br />-------------------------<br /> if you want to bring up old sh@t about QB's.. look at that punk BRADY.. when NE was @ SD brady was at an Angels game.. didn't even go see his "boys" play.. ok with that said.. i think it might be time to bench ben as well.. leftwich came into the skins game(in a pretty good situation considering how well the steelers D was playing that night) and played very well. he didn't make any mistakes, and he didn't put the steelers defense in a bad situation. exactly the opposite of what ben is doing. I'd rather have a healthy Byron than a beat-up Ben.. If he's hurt he should sit!! Arians needs to be replaced or at least start to make better decisions.. should have gone for it on 4

double-07double-07
(Report inappropriate content)

mdmike makes some good points. Time to put Big Ben on the shelf and let him rewind his clock. Leftwich is more than adequate until Ben's return.

bmm0321bmm0321
(Report inappropriate content)

First, I'm not trying to medically diagnose Roethlisberger from the comfort of my study, but looking at the steady deteriorization of his level of performance, granted, from afar, makes it dificult not to offer speculation.<br /><br />Let's be honest, Roethlisberger has not really been the same QB since his motorcycle accident a couple of years ago in which he sustained very serious injuries - he appears a step slower (he never was fast) and less agile when avoiding the rush. And, it is clear his accuracy is not as sharp.<br /><br />It may be possible to explain his lessened effectiveness, at least in large part, by further physical deterioration associated with his previous motorcycle injuries, deteriorization which likely has been exacerbated by the physical pounding associated with playing and accompanied by an inability to effectively compensate for said deterioration and adequately recouperate from week to week. <br /><br />All of this leads me to agree - he needs rest with very limited activity. The problem is, he is in the middle of a season.<br /><br />Unfortunately, I think Roethlisberger needs an extended rest - at least a month, maybe the rest of the year. He needs only limited activity during the coming off-season with a diet taylored to his reduced level of activity and body chemistry. <br /><br />I'm not liking what I'm seeing physically from Roethlisberger, and haven't for quite some time. Let Leftwich play.

mdmikemdmike
(Report inappropriate content)

Hey bountyhunter236......Don't forget Doofusburger throwing his receivers under the bus by whining he needs a tall receiver in the draft. As I recall "Smiley" Ward didn't appreciate his comment. Classless piece of ---t!

bostfanbostfan
(Report inappropriate content)

All around, a good article by the Czar.<br /><br />The Coach of the Year is a tough one, as he stated: You have to admire what Smith has done in Atlanta, but at the same time acknowledge the year-in, year-out excellence of Jeff Fisher. He is obviously one former return man who didn't take one too many to the head. lol Meanwhile, Falcons fans can console themselves that Smith has put last year's debacle in the rear view mirror and gotten their franchise competitive again. Ryan certainly looks like he has a bright NFL future. In what should have been a rebuilding year, he's given the city something to cheer about.<br /><br />Kudos to Herm Edwards for a gutsy call. Personally, I like to see coaches and teams play for the win and not the tie.<br /><br />So all the Dolphins needed was a bit of Tuna Surprise. lol You wonder why Dallas seems incohesive this year? That's because Parcells took some of the better coaches with him -- coaches that could have put certain Dallas egos in place in that lockerroom.<br /><br />Lastly, there is a bright side for the Lions: they'll get the first pick in the draft -- and no Matt Millen to blow it on yet another worthless receiver. Czar is right, more than anything the Lions need a good personnel guy right now to get back on track.

bmm0321bmm0321
(Report inappropriate content)

colts1888, ya you won this one, but you won't if they meet again. You're not going to get the gifts you got last Sunday. Remember the 2005 season? Big baby Peyton will be tossing the ball on the ground like he did last Sunday when he was sacked. Who can ever forget his big baby comment after they lost that playoff game at home," I mean somebody has to block". Way to throw your O line under the bus after a big loss you classless piece of ---t!

bountyhunter236bountyhunter236
(Report inappropriate content)

 advertisement

FOX SPORTS STORE

 advertisement

Statistical Information provided by: STATS LLC
© 2009 Fox Sports Interactive Media, LLC. All rights reserved.