Video Archive Search

Time now for our state farm double coverage and don't -- It came up from a conference call this week we're discussing which quarterback would you rather have in a must win game Peyton. Or Eli Manning you guys were actually truly split down the middle -- -- surprised -- that what was told you to make an argument well. My first arguments the simplest way is the fact that. Eli is too. Two world titles and Peyton has won Peyton has also lost one and the one that he lost he threw the interception reporter that he took back 74 yards. Also apply just look at just playoffs Manning has been Payton been in nineteen. Are right he's only won eleven if you look at Eli Eli. It's actually eight of eleven but in those eight he is fifteen touchdown passes and two interceptions he commands everything in the fourth quarter pulled a little better than -- hold -- -- and yet you all don't I like your numbers thank you but numbers don't lot. You Peyton got and new supporting cast you know Bruener. Players and he's got more touchdowns less interceptions higher percentage completion. He's got more wins and give back in time you get those -- you get more wins 38. -- -- -- -- very yeah our signal or some other. What YE at the track we're gonna proven big game their big moment at the Manning camp I don't put up. Outside spot in the Super Bowl how big would that the tire replay okay off the help they -- Miami. Little lucky not lucky we -- -- with that Jimmy Butler and David Eli Manning all day every day. I would you know we're we're talking about some. Two Brothers that are about 232 Super Bowl MVPs three and three Super Bowl titles four league MVPs. Just supportive perspective. You're good either way but I personally I just think forget about the numbers forget about the insignificant games in the wins and all that. I'm going on -- one thing. I just think for whatever reason. It's a magical year we saw with the Giants we've seen with individual players I think it's a magical year for Peyton. If not I don't really did my being but I must say this. I'm not necessarily just gonna -- based this off of this year I believe that if you give -- On neutral offense and you take Eli and you take Peyton. Eli will say okay I've got to run 60% of the time in the win I'll do it I don't think Peyton converted able want to get out to be the final word go so yeah they need to hold for later on -- save it for the playoffs I think there's a debate will continue to blow. Looking like -- headed towards the playoffs.